Cummings v. Lynn
Syllabus & Case Posture
Cummings, assignee, v. Lynn.
Assignment of bond.
Under tho act of 1718, the assignee of one holding the equitable interest in a bond, cannot sue in his own name.
The assignor of a bond is not liable to the assignee, on the failure of the obligor to pay, where there is no special covenant for that purpose.
This was an action of covenant, and the circumstances under which it came before the court, were these : The plaintiff filed a declaration to the following words:
“ Joseph Lynn, late of the county of Philadelphia, yeoman, was summoned to answer James Cummings, assignee of James Campbell and Stephen Kingston, who were assignees of George Turner, of a plea that he hold with him the covenants and agreements of him the said Joseph, with the said George made, according to the force, form and effect of a certain deed thereof by him the said Joseph, with the said George made, &c. And thereupon, the said James Cummings saith, that on the 6 th day of February, in the year of our Lord, one thousand seven hundred and eighty-four, xt the county aforesaid, a certa.n Nicholas Eveleigh, of the state of South Carolina, by his certain obligation or writing obligatory, sealed with his seal, and to the court here shown, whose date is the day and year aforesaid, acknowledged himself to be held and firmly bound unto a certain Lewis Lester jette, in the sum of three hundred and sixty-four pounds, twelve shillings, sterling money, in gold or silver specie, at the rate of four shillings and eight pence to the dollar, or one pound, one shilling and nine pence to the guinea, to be paid to the said Lewis, his certain ^attorney, executors, administrators and assigns, r*.. when he should afterwards be thereto required. And the said James ^ Cummings in fact saith, that the same sum of money, or any part thereof, being in no wise .paid or satisfied, a certain Joseph Parker, for whose use and benefit the obligation or writing obligatory aforesaid was made as aforesaid, afterwards, to wit, on the twelfth day of May, in the year of our Lord, 1784, at the county aforesaid, by his certain deed of assignment, on the obligation or writing obligatory aforesaid, under his hand and seal, duly made and executed, before two credible witnesses, did assign, indorse and make over the obligation or writing obligatory aforesaid, to the said Joseph Lynn, as by the same deed of assignment, to the court here shown, appears. And the said James Cummings further in fact saith, that the said Joseph Lynn, after-wards, to wit, on the- 8th day of September, in the year last aforesaid, at the county aforesaid, the said sum of money, or any part thereof, being in no wise paid or satisfied, by his certain deed of assignment, on the said writing obligatory, under his hand and seal, duly made and executed, before two credible witnesses, did assign, indorse- and make over the said obligation or writing obligatory, to the said George Turner, for value received of him. And the said James Cummings further in fact saith, that the said Joseph Lynn, in and by his said deed of assignment, did covenant and agree to and with the said George Turner and his assigns, that the sum of money aforesaid should be well and truly paid to the said George Turner, or his assigns, agreeable to the said obligation or writing obligatory, as by the same deed of assignment, to the court here shown, appears. And the said James Cum-, mings further in fact saith, that the said George Turner, afterwards, to wit, on the 18th day of November, in the year last aforesaid, at the county aforesaid, the said sum of money being in no wise paid or satisfied, did, by his certain deed of assignment, on the said obligation or writing obligatory, duly made and executed, under his hand and seal, before two credible witnesses, assign, indorse and make over the said obligation or writing obligatory to the said James Campbell and Stephen Kingston, and their assigns, for value received of them, and by the same deed of assignment, the said George did then and there covenant with the said James Campbell and Stephen Kingston, and their assigns, that the said sum of money should be well and truly paid to the said James Campbell and Stephen Kingston, or their assigns, agreeable to the said obligation or writing obligatory, as by the same deed of assignment, to the court here shown, appears. And the said James Cummings further in fact saith, that the said James Campbell and Stephen Kingston, afterwards, to wit, on the eighteenth day of December, in the year last aforesaid, at the county aforesaid, the said sum of money being in no wise paid or satisfied, by their certain deed of assignment, on the said obligation or writing obligatory, duly made and executed, under their hands and seals, before two credible *witnesses, did assign, indorse and make over the obligation or writing obligatory to the said James Cummings, and by the same deed of assignment, the said James Campbell and Stephen Kingston did then and there covenant with the said James Cummings, that the said sum of money should be well and truly paid to the said James Cummings, agreeable to the said obligation or writing obligatory, as by the same deed of assignment, to the court here shown, appears. Yet the said Nicholas Eveleigh, or the said Joseph Parker, or the said Joseph Lynn, or the said George Turner, or the said James Campbell, or Stephen Kingston, the sum of money aforesaid, or any part thereof, to the said James Cummings, although often required, hath not paid ; by reason whereof, action hath accrued to the said James Cummings, to demand and have the said sum of money of and from the said Joseph Lynn : nevertheless, the said Joseph Lynn, the same sum of money, or any part thereof, to the said James Cummings, hath not paid, although, to do this, the said Joseph Lynn, afterwards, to wit, on the 19th day of the same month of December, in the year last aforesaid, at the county aforesaid, was, by the said James Cummings required, but the same to him to pay hath hitherto refused, and still doth refuse ; to the damage of the said James Cummings, one thousand pounds, lawful money of the state of Pennsylvania ; and thereof he bringeth suit, &c.”
Opinion of the Court — The Chief Justice
Primary OpinionThe Chief Justice
now delivered the unanimous opinion of the court: That the assignment by Joseph Parker to Joseph Lynn was not an assignment according to the act of assembly (1 State Laws 77), but only a transfer of the equitable interest in the bond ; and that Joseph Lynn could not, by virtue thereof, maintain an action against the obligor, in his own name. The bond was payable to Lestarjette ; and, although Parker might have released it, it could only, at common law, be sued or assigned by the former. See Jenk. Cent. 221, ea. 75.
That Joseph Lynn, the defendant, only assigned his equitable interest in the bond to George Turner. It appears, indeed, manifestly, by tht previous assignment of Jacob Parker (which was equally known to Turner and to Lynn), that he had no other interest to assign. It is, therefore, the mere transfer of a chose in action : and even if an action of covenant might have been brought by George Turner against Lynn, on the word assigned ; yet no such action could be maintained against him, by the present plaintiffs, as Lynn’s assignment is not made to George Turner and his assigns.
That the covenant implied by the word assigned, extends only to this, that the assignee should receive the money from the obligor to his own use ; and if the obligee should receive it, that, then the assignor would be answerable over for it.
By the Court. — For these reasons, let judgment be entered for the defendant.
The decision in this case is said hy Judge Duncan (in Folwell v. Beaver, 13 S. & R. 316), to have “been the acknowledged law ever since;” and ne added, “if it were res integra, I, for my own part, would give no further effect to the word assigned.” In Folwell «. Beaver, it was held, that the indorsement in blank by the payee of a sealed note, did not make him liable to the holder. See also Elliot v. Miller, Addis. 269; Graham v. Gondy, Id. 55, and the note to Wheeler v. Hughes, ante, p. 23.