SCOTUS-Cases.net

Davey v. Turner

1 U.S. 11 1764-09 1,737 Words
Full Case Caption
Hugh Davey et ux. v. Peter Turner
Official & Parallel Citations
1 Dall. 11 · 1 U.S. 11
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · 1 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Hugh Davey et ux. v. Peter Turner.

Deed of married woman.

A deed of the laud a feme covert, executed by herself and her husband, and acknowledged by her before a judge of the court of common pleas of the county, to have been freely and voluntarily executed by her, by which the land was conveyed to trustees for the joint lives of herself and husband, &c., was held to be good, under the practice of the province.

This cause came before the Court for a determination on a special verdict, which found, that the defendant’s late wife, Sarah, before her marriage, was seised of the lands in question in fee ; that after her marriage with the defendant, she and her husband joined in a conveyance to two trustees and their heirs, “ habendum to them and the survivor of them, and his heirs for ever, in trust nevertheless to and for the proper use and behoof of the said P. Turner and S., his wife, for and during their joint lives; and from and after the decease of either of them, then to and for the sole and proper use and behoof of the survivor of them, and his or her heirs for ever.” That the o-! said P. Turner and *S.,' his wife, appeared before W. P., Esquire, then J one of the justices of the court of common pleas, for the county of Philadelphia, and acknowledged the said indenture to be their deed, and that the said Sarah was, then and there, secretly and apart from her said husband, examined by the said W. P., and on such private examination did declare, that she did sign, seal and execute the said indenture, with her full, free and voluntary consent, which acknowledgment and examination was then indorsed by the said W. P., under his hand and seal, upon the indenture. The special verdict goes on and finds, that for fifty years and upwards, it had been the constant practice and usage of the province of Pennsylvania, in cases where baron and feme have been desirous to settle, sell and dispose of the estate of the feme, for the baron axt&feme to join in a deed or deeds, and for the/me to go before sofne justice of the peace, in the county where the lands lie, out of court, and for the said justice to examine such feme in private and ajiart from her husband, respecting her signing and executing such deed, and to interrogate her, whether she became a party to and executed such deed, with her full and free consent, and on her declaration that she freely consented, for the justice to certify the same under his hand and seal. And that a great number of titles to valuable estates in this province, were held under, and did depend upon, deeds executed by baron said, feme, in manner aforesaid. And that the titles to such estates had never before been called in question, but that such deeds of femes covert and their husbands had always been allowed to be given in evidence in courts of justice ; that scriveners had generally conducted themselves by this usage, in transferring estates, and that only two fines had ever been levied in this province for conveying the estates of femes covert. The jury further found, that the said Sarah died, without having any issue born alive, and the plaintiff’s wife was one of her heirs-at-law.

The principal question was, whether this mode of conveyance of the estates of femes covert could be supported by the usage, as found by the jury.

On the part of the plaintiff,

Opinion of the Court — By the Court,

Primary Opinion

By the Court,

after advisement. — These deeds, and this mode of examination of femes covert on conveying their estates, having generally prevailed in this province, from its settlement, and undergone, from time to time, the „. -, notice *o£ the courts of justice, it would he very mischievous now to *14] overturn them. The maxim communis error facit jus cannot operate more properly than in this case, and the court unanimously adjudge the law to be witb tbe defendant,

In the case of Lloyd v. Taylor, post, p. 17, a deed by the wife of her lands, without any separate examination, was sustained, on the same ground of communis error; and these cases have been recognised, and the principle upon which they were decided, adopted by Judge Washington in Milligan v. Dickson, 1 Peters’ C. C. 438. “This usage,” said that learned judge, referring to the practice of acknowledging letters of attorney, “forms one of the great and essential land-marks of real property in this state- and if the titles depending upon it are to be uprooted at this day, I will not be th. judge to commence the work of devastation. Never was there a case where the principle communis error facit jus was more strictly and necessarily applicable.” In 1770, the legislature passed an act confirming titles derived from femes covert, where there had been no separate examination, and established a mode by which the husband and wife might thereafter convey the estate of the wife (1 Sm. L. 307). The decisions under this act have settled the principle, that the wife’s acknowledgment must appear, on the face of the certificate, to have been made substantially as the act requires ; and parol evidence is not admissible to supply defects in the certificate. And it must appear, that the acknowledgment was made before the proper officer, in his proper county. (See 5 Binn. 296; 7 3. & R. 43.) The act of 3d April 1826 (P. L. 187), provides that no hond fide conveyance, previously made, shall be held invalid, by reason of any informality or omission in setting forth the particulars of the acknowledgment; but the case of an aeknowdgment before an incompetent officer seems not to have been provided for. See also 1 Binn. 470; 4 S. & R. 273; 5 Id. 289; 6 Id. 49, 143; 9 Id. 273; 14 Id. 84; 15 Id. 71.

Cited By Later Decisions (1)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).