SCOTUS-Cases.net

Respublica v. Caldwell

1 U.S. 150 1785-09 215 Words
Full Case Caption
Respublica v. Caldwell
Official & Parallel Citations
1 Dall. 150 · 1 U.S. 150
Court & Volume
Philadelphia Court of Oyer and Terminer · 1 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

SEPTEMBER SESSIONS, 1785.

Respublica v. Caldwell.

Indictment for nuisance.

It is no defense to an indictment for nuisance, in erecting a wharf on the public property, that it would be beneficial to the public.

This was an indictment for a nuisance, in erecting a wharf on the public property. • The defendant offered witnesses to prove that the erection of the wharf had been beneficial to the public, and therefore, not to be regarded as a nuisance. But—

Opinion of the Court — McKean, Chief Justice,

Primary Opinion

McKean, Chief Justice,

delivered the opinion of the court, that the evidence was inadmissible, for two reasons: First, Because it would only amount to matter of opinion, whereas, it is on facts the court must proceed ; and the necessary facts are already in proof. Secondly, Because it would be no justification ; for, on the same principle that the defendant might carry his wharf twelve feet, he could justify extending it farther ; or any other man might excuse a similar intrusion. Suppose, for instance, a street were 60 feet wide, 12 feet might be taken off it, without doing any material injury to the public property, or creating any great obstruction to passengers; yet surely this will not justify any man’s actually buildim» upon, and assuming the property of the twelve feet that could be tl’w spared.

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).