Stevenson v. Pemberton
Syllabus & Case Posture
* APRIL TERM, 1760.
William Allen, Chief Justice, Lawrence Growden and William Coleman, Justices.
Stevenson v. Pemberton.
Factor’s lien.
A. in the West Indies, being indebted to B. in Philadelphia, consigned goods to him, directing him to sell them on his (A.’s) account, and to apply the proceeds, after first satisfying himself, to the payment of other creditors; C., a creditor of A., attached the goods in the hands of B., before sale: Held, that B. was entitled to retain the goods for the payment of his own debt.
Scire eacias against defendant as garnishee. The case was : C. in the West Indies was indebted to P., the defendant, for bills of exchange drawn by C., in favor of P., which were protested; P., by letter, solicits C. for security ; C. consigns a quantity of rum to P., and by letter directs P. to sell the same for his (C.’s) account, and apply the proceeds to the ¡payment of some protested bills, drawn by C. in favor of other people, “ first being satisfied that his (P.’s) bills were paid.” The bills of lading express this rum to be shipped on the proper account and risk of C. The rum comes into P.’s hands, but before any sale, the plaintiff, S., a creditor of C., brought a foreign attachment against C., and attached these goods in the hands of P. The question on these facts, as found by a special verdict, was — whether P. should retain the goods for the payment of his own debt, or whether the property remained in C., so as to be liable to the attachment of S. ?
Opinion of the Court — *By the Court.
Primary Opinion*By the Court.
This rum appears to have been sent to satisfy P.’s debt. If it had been money, there could have been no doubt but the defendant would have retained it. And the only difference is, that a commodity was sent, which must be converted into money, before the sum to be paid to P. could be ascertained ; but, as to P.’s interest in it, tbe case was the same. Therefore, judgment, by the whole Court, was given for the defendant,
Chew and Moland, pro Quer. Galloway and Dickenson, pro Def.
See United States v. Vaughan, 3 Binn. 394; Corser a Craig, 1 W. C. C. 424; Sharpless v. Welsh, 4 Dall. 279; Moore v. Spackman, 12 S. & R. 291.