SCOTUS-Cases.net

Wallace v. Fitzsimmons

1 U.S. 248 1788-03 1,156 Words
Full Case Caption
Wallace, surviving partner, v. Fitzsimmons, special bail
Official & Parallel Citations
1 Dall. 248 · 1 U.S. 248
Court & Volume
Philadelphia County Court of Common Pleas · 1 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Wallace, surviving partner, v. Fitzsimmons, special bail.

Pa/rlnershvp.

Payment by the garnishee in a foreign attachment, of one-half of a debt attached for a partnership claim, to the executor of a deceased partner, is not sufficient to exonerate such garnishee, pro tanto, as against the surviving partner.

The case was this : Hoe & Harrison, of Virginia, being indebted to Wallace & Smith, Wallace, as surviving partner of Smith, issued a foreign attachment against them, and attached their effects in the hands of Fitzsimmons. Judgment was obtained on this attachment, at the third term ; and, afterwards, Fitzsimmons entered special bail. The cause then pro-*2491 cee<^e<l> until judgment was finally ^obtained against Hoe & Harrison, -1 and upon the return of a ea. sa., non sunt invenerunt, an amicable scire facias was entered against Fitzsimmons; judgment was thereupon obtained, and an execution issued for the whole sum recovered against the principals in the original suit. It appeared, that during these proceedings, the executor (who was also the brother) of Smith, the deceased partner, applied to Fitzsimmons, and forbade his paying more than one-half of the money to Wallace ; offering an indemnification for the payment of the rest to him, and alleging that the partnership was considerably indebted to the estate of the deceased. Fitzsimmons, accordingly, gave notice of this application to Wallace, and afterwards, paid one-half of the money to the executor ; although a letter from him to Wallace was produced, in which he had declared, that he would not pay it either to him or to Smith, but that the law should take its course, and determine the right between the executor and the partner.

A rule was obtained which, in the argument, the counsel consented to consider, either as a rule to show cause why, on paying to the plaintiff 1151. (being one-half of the sum recovered from Hoe & Harrison), the proceedings on the execution should not be stayed ; or, as a rule to show cause why the execution should not be set aside, and the judgment opened, in order to let the defendant into a trial, on the plea of payment.

On this rule, two questions were brought before the court: 1st, In point of fact, whether Wallace had acquiesced in the payment of the executor? and 2d, In point of law, whether the payment to the executor did not discharge Fitzsimmons from the demand of the surviving partner ?

Opinion of the Court — Shippen, President.

Primary Opinion

Shippen, President.

It may probably be a hardship upon the defendant, but he has certainly made himself liable to the plaintiff’s demand. A payment to an executor or administrator, can be no satisfaction to a surviving partner, who has the sole right of suing for, and of receiving the moneys due to the company. The point of law is, therefore, exceedingly clear. Nor can we, in this manner, attempt to investigate the partnership accounts.

With respect to the point of fact, it does not seem to be at all established. If, indeed, the acquiescence of the plaintiff had been proved, we should have thought it a proper subject for a jury to determine. But, as the matter stands, we must leave the defendants his consolation, that even if he has not already taken an indemnification, he may recover the money back from the executor, having paid it in his own wrong.

The rule discharged,

а) Bell v. Newman, 5 S. & R. 86; Penn v. Butler, 4 Dall. 354. See Alexander v. Coulter, 2 S. & R. 494;

Precedents Cited (1)

Cited By Later Decisions (1)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).