Wilcox v. Henry
Syllabus & Case Posture
Wilcox et al. v. Henry.
Forfeiture.
A prior bwA fide sale of enemy’s property to a citizen, during the enemy’s occupation, will prevail over a subsequent seizure thereof, as forfeited.
The case was this: — In the close of the year 1777, one Stephen Back-house arrived at Philadelphia, from Liverpool, the troops of the king of Great Britain being at that time in possession of the city. Backhouse brought with him a large and valuable cargo of salt, which he stored in the warehouse of one Pritchard, and after a short stay in Philadelphia, he went to New York (then likewise in the possession of the British troops), consigning the salt to Messrs. Jones, Backhouse and Foulk, of Philadelphia, with directions that they should sell it for him, at the best price they could get, but not under a dollar per bushel. Backhouse, one of the consignees, was no relation whatever of Backhouse the owner. The consignees, accordingly, sold part of the salt to different persons, and on the 17th of June 1778, they sold the remainder to Wilcox, the plaintiff. On the 18th of June 1778 (the day succeeding the sale), the British troops evacuated Philadelphia. In January 1779, it was seized for the commonwealth, as the property of the enemy. And the question was, whether the salt was the property of Wilcox, the plaintiff; or became forfeited to the state of Pennsylvania, as being the property of a British subject ?
It is to be observed, that no money was paid by Wilcox to the consignees, at the time of the sale, though the key of the store was delivered to him. The price of the salt was to be a dollar per bushel; and the agreement, at the sale, was, that if the salt should be in the city, when the American army entered it, then the money should be paid for it within (I think) two or three months; but that if the salt should be destroyed or taken by the British troops, in that event, the contract should be null and void. These conditions were annexed to the agreement, from a general apprehension that the ^ -. British, *on evacuating the city, would either destroy such stores as J they did not want, or take with them those articles which they might stand in need of.
These facts, likewise, appeared in evidence, on the trial; that the consignees had been applied to by one of the plaintiffs, five or six days before the evacuation, to purchase the salt; that for three or four weeks before the evacuation, the citizens of Philadelphia supposed it was intended; that the whole of the British army did not finally leave the city until the morning of the 18th, though their shipping, for a fortnight before, had been, from time to time, dropping down the river; that the price of salt at that time was only three shillings per bushel; and that the plaintiffs have since, to wit, in August 1778, paid the full value of the salt, at the rate of a dollar per bushel, to Jones & Co.
Opinion of the Court — McKean, C. J.
Primary OpinionThe Chief Justice delivered a charge to the jury of the following purport:—
McKean, C. J.
As the counsel on both sides have quoted many eases, but have not appealed to the court for their opinion on the different points of law, the jury must take the whole together, and form their own judgment upon the subject.
Lewis and Wilson, for the plaintiffs. Bradford and Ingersoll, for the defendant.
When the British army evacuated Philadelphia, there was a debate in Congress, whether all the property found in the city, and belonging to the king of Great Britain, or any of his subjects, should appertain to the United States, or to the state of Pennsylvania only. It was at length agreed, however, that all public property, such as cannon, artillery, &e., should belong to the United States, and the private property of individuals should belong to the state of Pennsylvania.
An alien enemy has no right of action whatever during the war ; but by the law of nations, confirmed by universal usage, at the end of the war, all the rights and credits, which the subjects. of either power had against the other, are revived ; for, during the war, they are not extinguished, but merely suspended. If, also, a conquered country is ceded, the old possessors are entitled to their estates ; and when any country is conquered, the possessors are not deprived of their estates, but only change their masters. This is clearly the case between two independent powers, but how will the case be between this country and Great Britain, at the close of the war ? Why, had we been conquered, our lives and all our property would have been the forfeit ; but even as the business now stands, the subjects of Great Britain may, perhaps, claim a revival of the debts due to them from the citizens of America, whilst we, by their acts of parliament, are debarred of the like privilege. It is hard, that the people of America should, during the war, receive *72l ^continental money for specie, and, at the end of it, be deprived of J the debts due to them from abroad, whilst they are obliged to pay the debts due from them to British subjects. Unless some care is taken, this may be the case. I would hope, therefore, that the assemblies of the different states will think seriously of it, and, with a view it may be attended to, I have given this hint upon the present public occasion.
With respect to the case before the court, the Chiee Justice seemed strongly with the plaintiffs, and the jury found a verdict for them accordingly.
See Russel v. Skipwith, 6 Binn. 347; s. c. 1 S. & R. 310; Crawford v. The William Penn, 1 Peters C. C. 107; s. c., 3 W. C. C. 484.