M'Knight v. Craig's Administrator
Syllabus & Case Posture
M'KNIGHT v. CRAIG’S ADMINISTRATOR.
In Virginia, if the defendant die after interioustory judgment and a writ of inquiry awarded his administrator, upon scired facius, can only plead what his intestate could have pleaded.
ERROR-to the circuit court for the district of Golumbia, sitting'at-Alexandria; in an action of debt upon a judgment and devastavit, brought By JVTKnight against Craig, as executor of Mitchell.
, After an office judgment by default against Craig, . , J ° , . ,, ° i . and a ,writ or inquiry avyarded m November,. 1807, . at the rules, Craig died. At the July term, Í 808, his • death was suggested,and a scire jactas awarded against I. G. Ladd, his administrator. At the July term, 1809,. .(being the fpurth term after the office judgment,) Ladd appeared; by his. attpmeyj, and offered tp plead á special plea of plene apmihistravit, by himself, as administrator of Craig, to which the plaintiff objected, but the court overruled the objection, and admitted the plea to be filed.
In all cases ®f reversal, if this court direct the court' below to'enter judgment for the plaintiff in error, the court below will, of course, enter the judgment .with the costs of that court.
The sjtbstance .of the- plea was, that Craig had made a deed of trust of'certain real estate, fo secure Ládd for his endorsements, for Craig at the bank, by which deed . Craig covenanted to indemnify Ladd. That Ladd had endorsed the notes of ¡Craig to the amount of ¿,000 dollars, which were discounted at the bank, and continued the endorsements to the time of Craig?s death. That .the bank had recovered judgment against Ladd as endorsor of spme of ¡those notes to the amó.únt óf 6,009 ■ dollars, and that Ladd had paid Other of the said notes to the amount of 3,174 dollars, to avoid being compelled by suit to pay the sam.e. T,hat the estate, mentioned in the deed of trust, having been sold, producedonly 4,095'dollars, whereby the estate of-Craig became indebted-to Ladd hi the sum of 5,138 dollars,, and so much of t,he? estate of Craig is liable to be retained by1 Ladd in satisfaction.
Opinion of the Court — Marshall, Ch. J.
Primary OpinionMarshall, Ch. J.
delivered' the opinion, of. the spurt to the following effect.
The. act of assembly of Virginia, is copied almost literally from the.English statute of 8 and 9 W. III. c. 11. The case in 6 Mod. is a. decision expressly upon that statute, and is precisely in point, that the defendant upon the scire.facias can only plead what the intestate could have pleaded; and that it is not to be considered as a proceeding against the representative of die deceased, but a continuance of the original action.
The plea is such as could not have been pleaded in the original action, and is therefore bad.
The judgment must be reversed, and the .emanded for the defendant to plead to me original action, if he should think proper.
To a question by E. J. Lee, the Chief Justice answered, that ’if the plaintiff, in error should obtain a judgment in the court below, it will of course be with costs. So in all cases of reversal, if this court direct .the court’ below to enter • judgment for the plaintiff in error, the court below will,.of course, enter the judgment with the costs of that court.
The .court below considered this case as coming witüin the act of congress, vol Up 71. passed 24 th 1789, Authorizes the court (t to render judgment for or against the executor gr adminisvr.qtor, as the case may require.” It does not appear whether that act. was taken into consideration by this court.