Ex parte Perry
Syllabus & Case Posture
Ex parte Perry.
This court will not by mandamus compel an inferior court to.reverse a decision made in the exercise of its jurisdiction.
Petition for mandamus.
The petitioners filed their libel against the ship “ Civilfa ” and the steam-tug “ Restless,” in the District Court of the United States for the Southern District of New York. The vessels were seized under process sued out- of that court,' but weré released on the claimant of each giving the requisite stipulation for value.
From a decree against the claimants they respectively prayed and perfected an appeal to the Circuit Court. A decree was there rendered, Oct. 26,1877, in favor of the libellants, amounting in damages, interest, and costs to the sum of §11,400.90, •which was apportioned equally between the two vessels. The decree provided that on the payment by the claimant of either vessel of one-half of the amount, with interest thereon to the date of payment, the proceedings against such vessel -and her •claimant be stayed for the. collection of the residue until the return by the marshal of. an execution unsatisfied against the claimant of the other vessel for the other half part of said amount, or until it should otherwise appear that the libellants were unable to enforce or collect the other part of said damages costs, and interest against the claimant of the other vessel by process from that court.
The court further adjudged that unless the decree be fulfilled or satisfied, or proceedings stayed on appeal by filing security within tep days after service of a copy of the decree upon the proctc 1 for the claimants, the stipulators, on the appeal to that court for damages and costs, should perform their engagements, or show cause within four days after the expiration of said ten days, or on the first day of jurisdiction thereafter, why execution should not issue against them, their goods, chattels, and lands -
Opinion of the Court — Mr. ■Cheep Justice Waite
Primary OpinionMr. ■Cheep Justice Waite
delivered the opinion of the court.
We cannot by mandamus correct the judicial errors committed by an inferior court in the progress of a cause. Ex parte Schwab, 98 U. S. 240. We can in this way., in a proper case, compel an inferior court to act, but cannot control its decisions while acting. In the present case if. appears that the Circuit Court has acted on the motion of the petitioner, and denied him what he asked. The object of this proceeding is to obtain from us an order requiring that court to reverse its former decision and grant the relief it has once refused. That is the office of a -writ of error or an appeal, and not of a .writ of mandamus. Ex parte Flippin, 94 U. S. 248; Ex parte Loring, id. 418. Neither is the case changed because the appropriate remedy may involve an inconvenient delay. In Ex parte Whitney (13 Pet. 404), it was held that a writ of mandamus ought not to be used to correct orders made by a judge in the exercise of his authority, even though such orders “ may seem to bear harshly or oppressively upon the party ” complaining..
Mandamus refused.