Moores v. National Bank
Syllabus & Case Posture
Moores v. National Bank.
1. The construction given by the Supreme Court of a State to a statute of limitations of the State will be followed by this court in a case decided the other way in the Circuit Court before the decision of the State court. •
2. The erroneous sustaining of a demurrer to a replication to one of several defences in the answer requires the reversal of a final judgment for the defendant, which is not clearly shown by the record to have proceeded upon other grounds.
Error to the Circuit Court of the United States for the Southern, District of Ohio.
The action was brought by Caroline A. Moores against the Citizens’ National Bank of Piqua, in March, 1878. The amended petition, filed on the 11th of February, 1S74, and subsequently amended by leave of court in some particulars, after a motion of the defendant to require the plaintiff to make it more specific, alleged that the defendant was a banking corporation duly incorporated under the laws of the United States in 1864, with a capital stock of one thousand shares of one hundred dollars each, of which the whole was paid in, and certificates issued to the stockholders ; that on the 15th of July, 1867, G. Volney Dorsey was president and Robert B. Moores was cashier, and they were charged with the keeping of its transfer - books and the issue of certificates of stock ; that on that day Robert B. Moores represented himself to the plaintiff, "and appeared on the books of the bpnk, to be the ownér of more than ninety-one shares, and she purchased of him ninety-one shares, and paid him therefor the sum of Si),100 in money, qnd he, as cashier and stockholder, 'falsely and fraudulently represented to her that he had, in consideration of such purchase and payment by her, assigned and transferred the ninety-one shares to her on the books of the bank, and thereupon Dorsey as president, and Robert B. Moores as cashier, signed and issued to her a certificate therefor in the usual form, that the plaintiff believed and relied upon the representations of Robert B. Moores, as cashier and stockholder, that the stock had been duly transferred by him to.her on the books of the bank, and that the certificate was duly issued and was valid; that she was recognized as a stockholder for that amount of stock until on or after the 1st of January, 1873, when she first learned that the defendant disputed the validity of the certificate, denied that any transfer had been made to her upon its books, and refused to recognize her as a stockholder; that after the issue of the certificate to .her the defendant fraudulently permitted and procured Robert B. Moores to make on its books transfers of all the stock owned by him, or standing in his name, to Dorsey, its president, for its benefit, and refused, and still refuses, to recognize the plaintiff as owner of the stock, or to recognize the validity of the certificate; that the facts that no transfer had been made to the plaintiff on the books of the .bank at the time of the issue and delivery of the certificate to her,, that the certificate was not authorized by the bank or recognized by it as valid, and that the stock standing in the name, of. Robert B. Moores had been transferred on the books to its president, were'fraudulently concealed by the defendant, through its cashier, Robert. B. Moores, and she was aware of .no circumstances calling lor inquiry on her part until after the 1st of January, 1873; that, by reason of the fraudulent con- • duct and acts aforesaid of the defendant, the certificate was Invalid and worthless in her hands, and she had lost the sum of $9,100 paid by her therefor; and that the defendant had • been requested by the.plaintiff to repay or reimburse that sum to her, or to recognize the validity of the certificate, and had refused so to do.
The defendant filed an answer, setting up three grounds of .defence: 1st, Averring that the plaintiff’s alleged cause of action did hot accrue within four years next preceding the commencement of the action; and denying that the plaintiff was ignorant of the facts set forth in her petition, if they existed, or of facts which called upon her to inquire as to the validity of the certificate, until the 1st of January, 1878, or any other date after the 15th of July, 1867. 2d, Averring that, pursuant, to an agreement made by the plaintiff and her husband, with Robert B. Moores and William B. Moores on the 15th of July, 1867, which the .defendant had no knowledge ,of, interest in, or connection with, the sum of $9,10.0 had been •repaid to the plaintiff by William for the paper purporting to be a certificate of stock, and Robert had thereby become entitled to take up the same. 3d, Averring that the paper purporting to be a certificate of stock was executed and delivered by Robert to the plaintiff, in violation of his duty, and without the knowledge or consent of Dorsey or any other officer of the defendant; that, according to the defendant’s rules and usages, no one could procuré a certificate of stock without the contemporaneous surrender of a certificate for an equal amount for cancellation-; and that before the 15th of July, 1867, all the shares previously held by Robert had been transferred by him, and on the books of the bank, to other persons.
Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice Gray,
Primary OpinionMr. Justice Gray,
after ■ stating the case, delivered the opinion of the court.
The principal embarrassment in this case, arises- from the difficulty of ascertaining from the prolix and obscure record what was actually decided in the court below.
The decision of that court sustaining the demurrer to the plaintiff’s first reply to the first ground of defence was based upon the position that the exception in the statute of limitations of Ohio in favor of a married woman was repealed by the statute of 1870, by which it was enacted that a married woman might sue alone in actions concerning her separate property. That decision was in accordance with an opinion of the majority of the,, Superior Court of Cincinnati in Ong v. Sumner, 1 Cincinnati Superior Court, 424, which appears to have been the only decision upon the question in the courts of Ohio at the time of the trial of the present case in the Circuit Court. But in Lawrence Railroad v. Cobb (35 Ohio St. 94), the Supreme Court of Ohio has since adjudged that, even if the statute of 1870 withdrew the protection of coverture (a point which it did not decide), yet the action of a married woman was not barred until four years after the passage of this statute; and the construction thus given to the statute by the highest court of the State should be followed by this court. Tioga Railroad v. Blossburg & Corning Railroad, 20 Wall. 137; Kibbe v. Ditto, 93 U. S. 674; Fairfield v. County of Gallatin, 100 id. 47.
It follows that the order sustaining the demurrer to the plaintiff’s first reply was erroneous, and that the judgment below in favor of the defendant must be reversed, unless it clearly appears that the plaintiff was not prejudiced by the error. Deery v. Cray, 5 Wall. 795; Knox County Bank v. Lloyd, 18 Ohio St. 353.
To the first ground of defence stated in the answer, namely, that the cause of action did not accrue within four years, the-plaintiff had made two replies: the first, in the nature of confession and avoidance, that she was a married woman; the second, in the nature of a traverse, that the action did accrue within four years. This allegation of fact, in the second reply cannot affect the issue of law raised by the defendant’s demurrer to the first reply. / After that demurrer had been sustained, the case, as was assumed and contended by the learned counsel for the defendant at the argument, presented three issues: First, Whether the cause of action accrued within four-years. Second, Whether there had been a payment, as alleged ■ in the second ground of offence. Third, Upon the third ground of defence, which included a general denial of all the material allegations in the petition.
A verdict of a jury, or, where a trial by jury is waived, a .finding by the court, upon any one of these issues, would be sufficient to sustain a general finding for the defendant, and would render the .other issues of fact immaterial. The bill of exceptions merely states generally that “ the court found for the defendant; ” and the statement in the record, that under a submission “ upon the issue joined ” the court found “ the issues ” to be in favor of the defendant, is too ambiguous to enlarge the effect of the general finding as stated in the bill of exceptions.
The sustaining of the demurrer to the plaintiff’s first reply deprived her of the right to insist upon the ground of action, which was open nnd^r the petition, that the defendant, more than four years before the action was brought, permitted and procured the transfer upon its books to other persons of shares of which the plaintiff held the certificate (Bank v. Lanier, 11 Wall. 369; Telegraph Company v. Davenport, 97 U. S. 369); and limited her, so far as regarded the first ground of defence, to proof of a cause of action accruing within the four years. The general finding in favor of the defendant may have proeeeded solely upon that ground of defence, without touching the second and third grounds.
The defendant therefore fails-to show that the error in sustaining its demurrer did not prejudice the plaintiff, and consequently the judgment must be reversed and a
New trial ordered.
Mr. Justice Matthews did not sit in this case.