Rives v. Duke
Syllabus & Case Posture
Rives v. Duke.
On "the -5th' of December, 1863, after the Proclamation of Emancipation, and in that part of Virginia the people of which were in rebellion against the United States, one resident therein sold and delivered to another a; number of slaves, with warranty of title, but not .of soundness, the purchaser covenanting “to pay on delivery the sum of $25,000 in bankable Confederate currency, and, in addition, fo give his note,” with two persons named as sureties, “ for the further sum of §20,000, to be paid in twelve months after call, in equal annual payments thereafter, or at the purchaser’s option it may be, on call, all or a part paid; ” and the seller covenanting “not to call upon the purchaser for specie when it is at a premium, but engaging on his part to he satisfied with the bankable currency of the day, on the stipulation to choose his oWn ' time for the call.” On the "1st of January,. 1864, the purchaser, in lieu of the note, made to the seller two bonds,-With the same persons as sureties, to pay $8,000 “ on demand, or twelve months thereafter, at the option of the obligors,” and $12,000 “on demand, or two years thereafter, at the option of the obligors,” “ in the bankable currency of the day, according to the agreement of the 5th of December last,” “ the said demand shall be made in writing by the obligee, his heirs or legal representatives only.” Payment of the bonds was demanded in writing by the obligee aftei- the 'end of the war of the rebellion, and when the bankable currency of Virginia consisted wholly of notes of the United States or of the national banks. Held, in an action on the '' bonds, that the plaintiff had no ground of exception, 1, to the admission of evidence that, at the time when the agreement and bonds were made, Confederate'currency was-bankable and was the only currency in circulation in Virginia, the value of gold in relation to such currency was as nineteen or' twenty to one, slaves were not selling at all for gold, and these slaves were not worth in Confederate currency so much as $45,000, and that' before the war, when the price' of slaves was at its highest, such a lot of slaves would not have been worth more than a fifth of that sum in gold; 2, to an'instruction to the jury that, if they found that the bonds were made in reference to Confederate currency, the plaintiff was entitled to recover .the amount, therein stipulated to be paid, at the value of Confederate money compared with national currency at the time of the making qf the bonds.
Ekkok to the Circuit Court of the United States for the Western District of Virginia,
This was an action of covenant, brought by the executor of the will, and prosecuted by the administrator de bonis non of George Rives, against Duke,, the administrator of the estate of William P. Parish, a surety on two bonds.
■ The declaration alleged that on the 5th .of December, 1863, in the county of Albemarle and State of Virginia, George Rives and George L. Peyton executed an'ágréement under seal, which began with a'“list of servants sold to George.L. Peyton” (giving the names and ages-of thirty-three negroes, the oldest of whom were fifty-one years of age, and the youngest w'ere infants), and the rest of which was as follows: “I have (his day contracted to sell and deliver on the place, on the 1st of January next, to George L. Peyton the above list of negroes, thirty-three in number. The title thereto I warrant, but make no warranty of soundness^ For the same negroes the said George L.' Peyton agrees to pay on delivery the sum of twenty-five thousand dollars in bankable Confederate currency, and in addition to give his note, with William P. Farish and William H: Peyton as sureties, for the further sum of twenty thousand', dollars,'to be paid in twelve months after call, in equal annual payments thereafter, or at said Peyton’s option it may be, on call, all or a part paid. Th.e said George Rives covenants he will not call on said Peyton for specie when ft is at a premium, but engaging on his part to, be satisfied with the bankable currency of the day, on the stipulation to choose' his own time for the call. The said postponed payment to carry interest from -1st January next, and to be annually paid at Monticello Bank. ■ The said George Rives farther engages to furnish said Peyton one hundred barrels of corn at $20 per barrel, to be delivered on the placé as soon as gathered, and the money therefor to be paid down in Confederate bankable currency. In witness' whereof, and mutual obligation to perform our respective engagements, we. this day, 5th of' December, 1863, have signed our hands and seals.”'
The declaration then alleged that on the 1st of January, 1864,. in pursuance of that agreement, Rives delivered the negroes to Peyton on the farm in Albemarle on which Rives then resided, which was “ the place ” referred to in the agreement, and also delivered the one hundred barrels of corn; and Peyton paid to Rives in bankable Confederate currency $25,000 in part payment of the purchase-money contracted to be paid for the slaves, and. gave to Rives his two bonds, executed by William P. Farish and William H. Peyton as sureties, amounting in the aggregate to $20,000, the first of which bonds was in these tefms: “On demand, or twelve months thereafter, at the option of the obligors, we promise to pay in the bankable currency of the. day (according to agreement of the 5th December last),'to George Rives, his heirs or assigns, eight thousand dollars with interest from date, to be annually paid on 1st January at Monticello Bank, Charlottesville; the same being in part of the purchase-money for thirty-three negroes, the title whereof is warranted, but no warranty is made of soundness. The said demand shall be made in'writing by said Géorge Rives; his assigns or legal representatives only. In witness whereof, we have hereto put our hands and seals this first day of January, 1864 ; ” and the other bond was precisely, like the first, except in substituting the words “ two years ” for “ twelve months,” and “ twelve thousand ” for “ eight thousand; ” and that these • bonds were delivered and accepted as a compliance on the part of Peyton with the provision in the previous agreement to give his note for-$20,000.
Opinion of the Court — Mk. Justice Guay
Primary OpinionMk. Justice Guay
delivered the opinion of the court.
It is settled by the decisions .of this court that a contract, made within the so-called Confederate States during the war of the rebellion, to pay a certain sum in dollars, without specifying the kind of currency in which ’it was to be paid, may be shown, by the nature of the transaction and the attendant circumstances, as well as by the language of the contract itself, to have contemplated payment in Confederate currency; and that if that fact is shown, in an action upon the contract, no more can be recovered than the value of that currency in lawful money of the United States. Thorington v. Smith, 8 Wall. 1; The Confederate Note Case, 19 id. 548, 559; Wilmington & Weldon Railroad Co. v. King, 91 U. S. 3.
By the bonds in-suit, the obligors promise to pay “on demand, or ” (in the first' bond) “ twelve months,” and (in the second bond) “two years thereafter, at the option of the obligors,” eight thousand and twelve thousand dollars respectively, “ in the bankable currency of the day, according to the agreement of the 5th December last.” In the agreement so referred to, which is a. contract for the sale of slaves, that part of the price which is to''be paid on the delivery is. clearly expressed to be “the sum of twenty-five thousand dollars in bankable Confederate currency; ” and the agreement, upon its face, affords strong ground for inferring that “the further sum' of twenty thousand dollars to' be paid in twelve months after call,” and as to which the seller covenants not to call for .specie, but to be satisfied- with the “bankable currency of the day,” is' also to be paid in Confederate currency, and that tbe effect of this clause is not varied by the omission to repeat therein the word “ Confederate,” the use of which, in the previous as well as in the subsequent part of the agreement, shows the kind of bankable currency which the parties to the agreement, and.to the bonds that refer to it, had in mind. And a consideration of the nature of the agreement, and of the circumstances under which it was made, removes. all doubt upon the subject.
It .was a .contract for the sale and purchase of slaves, made and to be performed in, between parties residing in, that part of the State of Virginia from which the ■ authority of the national government was excluded by the rebel armies, and was made after the Proclamation of Emancipation issued' by the President of the United States had declared all slaves in that district to be free. If the so-called Confederate States. should achieve independence, the money of the United States would be the money of a foreign country. If the national authority should be re-established over the insurgent districts,- the slaves, for part of the price of which the payment was to be -made, would be free, in fact' and in law, ánd be wholly lost to the purchaser. In view of either alternative, the parties cannot reasonably be held to have contemplated payment in any other currency than that of the Confederate States.
That part of the evidence .introduced by the defendant, of the competency of which, in the light of. the decisions in Thorington v. Smith and in The Confederate Note Case, above cited, there can be no question, leads to the same conclusion. It tended to prove that, at the time and place of the making of the agreement and of the bonds, the only currency in circulation or bankable was Confederate currency, the value of that currency in relation to gold was as one to nineteen or twenty, slaves were not being sold at all for gold, andUL e slaves were not worth more than the stipulated price computed in Confederate currency, and would never, even before the war, have been worth more than a fifth of that price in gold.
The competency of the evidence as to the popular expectation of an increase in the value of Confederate currency, and as to the price at which another person would or could have sold other slaves, is much more doubtful, and need not he considered, inasmuch as it was not specifically contested at the argument, probably because its exclusion could not vary the result,- so long as the evidence which we hold to be competent is admitted.
The facts of the case clearly distinguish it from Gavinzel v. Crump (22 Wall. 808), and bring it within that class of cases in which the Court of Appeals of Virginia has held contracts made during the war to bé payable in Confederate currency only. See M'Clung v. Ervin, Hilb v. Peyton, Bowman v. McChesney, and Calbreath v. Virginia Porcelain Co., 22 Gratt. (Va.), 519, 550, 609, 697.
For these reasons, we are all 'of opinion that the parties to the bonds in suit contemplated payment in Confederate currency ; and it is immaterial to consider whether, by reason of the option given to the seller in the original agreement, and to the obligors in the subsequent bonds, the value of that currency should be estimated as of the date of the bonds, or as of the date of tbe demand of payment, because the earlier, estimate, upon which the instructions of the court and the verdict of the jury proceeded, is the more favorable to the plaintiff.
As no error prejudicial to the plaintiff is shown in the rulings and instructions of the court, and as the défendant has not and' could not have brought a writ of error, it would be extra-judicial to pass upon the further position of the defendant, that the bonds sued on have no legal validity or effect.
Judgment affirmed.