SCOTUS-Cases.net

The "S. C. Tryon"

105 U.S. 267 1881-10 1,412 Words
Full Case Caption
The "S. C. Tryon."
Official & Parallel Citations
105 U.S. 267 · 26 L. Ed. 1026
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 105 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

The “S. C. Tryon.”

1. The findings of fact which, in admiralty cases in the Circuit Court, the act of Eeb. 16,1875, c. 77 (18 Stat., pt. 3, p. 315), requires are in the nature of a special verdict, and constitute a part of the record.. The law arising thereon will therefore be determined here, although no exception thereto was taken.

2. A bill of exceptions is required to reserve for review the rulings below upon questions of law during the progress of the trial.

3. The court in this case, while refusing to dismiss the appeal, grants a motion to affirm the decree, it appearing from the record that the appeal was taken for delay.

Motion to dismiss an appeal from the Circuit Court of the United States for the District of Maryland, with which is united a motion to affirm.

The Merchants’. Steamship Company, of Charleston, South Carolina, as owner, of the steamship “Falcon,” filed its libel in the District Court of the United States for the District of Maryland, in a cause of collision, civil and maritime, against the schooner “ S. C.' Tryon,” and' obtained a decree. The claimants thereupon appealed to the Circuit Court, which found the following facts: —

Opinion of the Court — .Mb. Chief Justice Waite

Primary Opinion

.Mb. Chief Justice Waite

delivered the opinion of the court..

A bill of exceptions is not necessary to give this court jurisdiction of an appeal in admiralty under the provisions of the act of Feb. 16, 1875, c. 77 (18 Stat., pt. 3, p. 315). That act expressly provides' that the review here shall extend to the determination of the questions of law arising upon the record, and to such rulings of the court, excepted to at the time, as may be presented by a bill of éxeeptions, prepared as in actions at law. At law á bill of exceptions is only used to put into the record that which would not appear without. . The findings which the statute requires must be stated by the court. These, therefore, become part of the record without any action of. the parties,, and errors of law arising on them need not be presented by exceptions. They are in the nature of a special verdict, as to which the inquiry is always open' in the reviewing court, whether, when taken in connection with everything else that appears, it is sufficient to support the.judgment.

The .motion to dismiss must, therefore, be overruled, but on looking into the; record we are satisfied the appeal was taken for delay. The only question presented arises on the findings of fact. From these it appears that the collision was due solely to an unjustifiable change of course by the schooner when the'vessels were in close" proximity, which baffled the steamer in her efforts to pass in safety. . It is so well settled that a steamer is not-liable for the consequences of a collision occurring in this way, that we do not deem it proper to retain the cause for further consideration.

Motion to affirm granted.

Cited By Later Decisions (6)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).