SCOTUS-Cases.net

United States v. Rindskopf

105 U.S. 418 1881-10 1,850 Words
Full Case Caption
United States v. Rindskopf
Official & Parallel Citations
105 U.S. 418 · 26 L. Ed. 1131
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 105 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

United States v. Rindskopf.

1. The court condemns the practice of setting out in the, bill of exceptions the entire charge of the court below, instead of confining it to such parts as are the subject of exception.

2. Suit on a distiller’s bond, the breach assigned being his non-payment of the tax due on a specified number of gallons of spirits alleged to have been distilled at his distillery between certain dates. Held, that prima facie proof of hfs liability is furnished by the assessment of the Commissioner of Internal Revenue; but it may be overcome by evidence showing either that the tax. was paid, or that the whole or a part of the spirits in question was not distilled, within the period mentioned.

3. The point in controversy being as to the quantity of spirits produced upon which the tax was not paid, the court below erred in charging the jury that the assessment must stand as an entirety or be wholly rejected.

Error to the. Circuit Court of the United States for the Eastern District of Wisconsin..

This is an action against 'Lewis Rindskopf, the principal, and Raphael Reichmann and Elias Rindskopf, sureties, on a distiller’s bond for $7,000, executed March 23, 1875. The principal was then engaged in the business: of a distiller within the first collection district of Wisconsin. The condition of the bond provided, among other things, that he should “ comply with all the provisions of law in relation to the duties and business of distillers.” ■ The complaint alleges as a breach of these conditions the non-payment of the tax due on 3,640 gallons of spirits distilled by him at his distillery between the 25th of April, and the 1st of..May, 1875, amounting to $3,276.- It also alleges ■that the Commissioner of Internal Revenue assessed the tax. against him on the special list -for October of that year; and that the assessment was returned to the collector of the district, who demanded payment of the tax, which was refused.

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice Field,

Primary Opinion

Mr. Justice Field,

after stating the case, delivered the opinion of the court.

. The bill of exceptions in this case sets forth the charge of the court below in full, in: disregard of our frequent condemnation of this' practice. Only the parts to which the exceptions relate should have, been given; all else is unnecessary, and produces only inconvenience. We repeat of this practice what we said of another practice not- uncommon, and equally objectionable,— that of inserting the entire evidence in the record: “ If counsel will not heed our admonitions upon this subject, so frequently expressed by us, the judges of the courts below, to whom the bills are presented, should withhold their signatures until the bills are prepared in proper form, freed from all matter not-essential to explain and point the exceptions.” Lincoln v. Laflin, 7 Wall. 132, 137.

The assessment of the Commissioner of Internal Revenue was only prima facie evidence of the amount due as taxes upon the spirits distilled between- the dates .mentioned. It established a prima facie case of liability against the distiller,- and . nothing more. If not impeached, it .was sufficient to justify a recovery; but every material fact upon which his. liability was asserted wks open to contestation. He and his sureties were at liberty to show that no spirits,.or a. less quantity than that stated by the commissioner, were distilled within the period-mentioned, and thus entirely, or in part, overthrow the assessment. They were also at liberty to show a payment of the tax assessed, in whole or in part, and thus discharge or reduce the distiller’s liability. To the extent, however, in which the •assessment was not impaired, it was evidence of the amount due. The court, therefore, erred in instructing the jury that the assessment was to be taken and considered in its entirety, and that the government was entitled to recover the exact amount assessed, or not-any sum. In other respects the charge, as. given above, correctly presents the law.

There may undóubtedly be cases where an assessment • must stand as an entirety, or not at all; as where an erroneous rate-has been adopted by the officer; ok where it is impossible to separate from the property assessed the part- which is exempt from the tax; or where its validity depends upon the jurisdiction of the commissioner. The present case does not fall within either of these classes. Here the question is as to the quantity of-spirits produced on which taxes were not paid.'

•The decree in the equity suit was properly- held not to be a bár to. the prosecution of this action in the absence of proof that the assessment which it .adjudged invalid covered the spirit's upon which the assessment-here was made. . The .instruction to- the - jury deprived it of any weight as evidence- with them.

Judgment reversed', and cause-remanded for a new trial.

Precedents Cited (1)

Cited By Later Decisions (6)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).