SCOTUS-Cases.net

The "New Orleans"

106 U.S. 13 1882-10 1,236 Words
Full Case Caption
The "New Orleans."
Official & Parallel Citations
106 U.S. 13 · 27 L. Ed. 96 · 1 S. Ct. 90
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 106 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

The “New Orleans.”

1. The court, upon the facts found by the Circuit Court, affirrhs. the decree whereby the steamer “ New Orleans ” was condemned to pay the damages occasioned by her collision with a schooner. . ' •

2. The evidence which in another suit a part owner of the schoorilf gave as to the extent and cost of the repairs put upon her, is not in this suit admissible against the other part owners.

Appeal from the Circuit Court of the United States for the Southern District of New York.

The owners of the “ Allie Bickmore ” filed, in their' own behalf and as carriers of her cargo, their libel in a cause of collision, civil and maritime, against the “ New Orleans.” The District Court adjudged the “ New Orleans ” to be wholly in fault, and rendered a final decree accordingly for $15,682.37, with interest thereon and costs. Both parties appealed to the Circuit Court, which found the following facts : —

1. A little after five o’clock in the morning of the 6th of September, 1874, a collision occurred between the schooner “ Allie Bickmore,” owned by the libellants, and tbe steamer “ New Orleans,-” in the Atlantic Ocean, about forty miles southeasterly from Cape Henlopen. •

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice Field

Primary Opinion

Mr. Justice Field

delivered the opinion of the court.

The findings of the Circuit Court, which are conclusive here, show that the steamer’was wholly in fault for its collision with the schooner; and she was therefore justly condemned to pay all the damages inflicted.

The only question open for our consideration arises upon the exception to the exclusion by the commissioner of the testimony given in another suit by one of the part owners of the schooner as to the extent and value of. its repairs. The exclusion, we think, was correct. The statements of the part owner, expressing his -judgment as to the matters upon which he was examined, could, at most, bind only himself. They were not evidence against. his co-owners, who were merely tenants in common with him, not partners. Story on Partnership, sect. 453. ' •

Decree affirmed.

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).