United States v. Phelps
Syllabus & Case Posture
United States v. Phelps.
1. A claim for the appraisement of goods and the reduction of the duty thereon, by reason of the damage which they sustained during the voyage of importation, may be allowed, although'not made until after they were entered at the custom-house at their full invoice value and ■ the estimated duties thereon paid. Shelton v. The Collector, 5 Wall. 113, so far as it conflicts with this ruling, is overruled.
2. Section 2928, Rev. Stat., has exclusive reference to goods taken from a wreck.
Error to the Circuit Court of the United States for the Southern District of New York.
Phelps Brothers & Co. imported, August, 1876, from foreign parts into the port of New York 5,861 boxes of lemons, the value of which at the market when and where they were purchased was $24,006. ‘ The duty on them, at twenty per cent ad valorem, was $4,801.20, the payment of which was admitted by the United States except $1,151.60, to recover which sum this action was brought against the importers in the proper District Court of the United States.
The plaintiff having proved the foregoing facts, the defendants offered evidence showing that they, on the day of the importation of' the lemons, made an entry thereof at the custom-house in New. York at their full invoice price, and paid the estimated amount of duty thereon, if they were in sound condition; that within seven days thereafter the defendants applied for an allowance for damage to the lemons on the voyage, and that after a subsequent examination and appraisement of the damage an allowance was thereupon made, the duties whereon, at twenty per cent, amounted to $1,151.60, in accordance wherewith the entry was liquidated in October of that year and the United States, paid that sum to the defendants.
Opinion of the Court — Mr. Chief Justice Waite
Primary OpinionMr. Chief Justice Waite
delivered the opinion of the court.
Section 2928 of the Revised Statutes, a re-enactment of sect. 21 of the act of March 1, 1823, c. 21, relates alone to merchandise taken from a wreck, and does not in any manner affect the proceedings under sect. 2927, a ré-enactmént of sect. 52 of the act of March 2, 1799, c. 22, to obtain an appraisement for an abatement of duties on account of damages to goods during the voyage of. importation. What -was said in Shelton v. The Collector, 5 Wall. 113, 118, to the contrary of this is disapproved. The subject is so fully and carefully considered in the opinion of the court below, that we deem it unnecessary to do more than to refer to the report of the case in 20 Blatchf. 129.
Judgment affirmed.