Beatty v. Maryland
Syllabus & Case Posture
BEATTY v. THE STATE OF MARYLAND.
IJresent....Ml the Judges.
a final account settled by an iidministratoi* pha^s Court", »°t ooñciutahisfevornp-. on the' issue of JJo™staYit Vl!l
ERROR to the Circuit Court for the district of Columbia, sitting in Washington.
This was an action of debt brought at the instance and for the use of Thomas Corcoran against Thomas Beatty upon the administration bond of Mrs. Doyle, administratrix,' with the will annexed, of Alexander Doyle. 'The Defendant was one of her sureties in that bond. The Defendant' after oyer pleaded a special performance of every item in the condition of. the bond; To which the Plaintiff replied ajudgment.de bonis testatoris obtained by him, in May, 1799, against the ádministratrix, fieri facias upon that judgment and a return of nulla bona. The replication also afers that the administratrix had in her hands, atthe time of the judgment, goods of her testator sufficient to satisfy the debt, hut th§it she wasted them. The Defendant took isshp upon the devastavit.
Upon the trial of this issue, the Defendant below took, a bill of excepsions which stated — that the Plaintiff offered in evidence the record of the judgment in May, 1799, against the administratrix for 357 dollars, and the fieri facias returned nulla bona. And also the inventory which she had .exhibited to the orphans Court of Montgomery county, in Maryland, in January, 1795-amounting'to ¿.3701 2 7 Maryland currency, o? Which 2001. is stated in the inventory to be cash. Also an account' of the administratrix with tiie éstáte of her testator, rendered by her to the Orphan’s Court upon oath on 17th of August,- 1799, in which she charges herself with the sum oí11085Z. in' addition to the former inventory, making in the whole 4788Í, and claims credit for sums paid to other creditors whose claims- were not entitled to pi-eferencc, amounting to 35661.- — leaving a balance still in her hands of 1220¿. equal to 3253 dollars, and also a second account rendered by her upon oath to the Orphan’s Court in November, 1799, charging herself with a further sum of assets to the amount of ¿.463 ±5 5 in addition1 tó the former balance and claiming credit for ¿.1607 16 11 paid to sundry creditors not entitled to preference, and still leaving a balance-of 76Z. in her hands to be administered. The Defendant then offered in evidence, a third account rendered by the administratrix to the Orphan’s Court in 1801, in which She charges herself with the former balance of 76Í. and claims, allowance for. payments and commissions to the amount of 123¿. leaving a balance in her favor of 47¿. To this account, as well as to the two former,, was annexed a certificate from the register of wills, that the administratrix made oath on the' Holy Evangels of Almighty God, that the account Was just, and true as it stood stated, and that she had bonaJlde paid or. secured to be paid the . several Sunfs for which she claimed an álldwanceaóhich after due examination passed by order of Court.”
Opinion of the Court — Duvall, J. Marshall, Ch. J.
Primary OpinionDuvall, J.
The account was ,only binding upon the representatives of the éstate, the distributees; and they might still open it in the general Court. But the creditors are no parties1 to the settlement of the account, and cannot be bound by it.
There can be no . doubt that the judgment against the administratrix, the inventory and two first accounts were conclusive evidence of a devastavit.
Marshall, Ch. J.
I believe that is the law throughout the United States.
The Court is unanimously of opinion that the settlement of the account by tlie Orphan’s Court is not conclusivo evidence for the Defendant upon the issue joined.
Judgment affirmed.