Brig Caroline v. United States
Syllabus & Case Posture
BRIG CAROLINE, WILLIAM BROADFOOT, CLAIMANT, v. THE UNITED STATES.
A libel for a i'qrfeiture must be particular and certain in all the material tut” the of-fence. mationinrem, «tended6 by leave of the Court.
ERROR to the Circuit Court for the district of South Carolina, in a case of seizure lor violation of the acts of, Congress respecting the slave trade.
The libel was in the words following;
, rt «At a special district Court for South Carolina district, Be it remembered, That on the day of in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and the United States of America, by Parker, tlr ir attorney for the district aforesaid, came here into Court anti gave Thomas Bee, esq. judge of the said Court, to understand and be informed that on the day of they, the said United States, by their proper officers of the customs, did cause to be seized, arrested and secured, a certain brig or vessel called the Caroline, her tackle, furniture, apparel and other appurtenances, as forfeited to them, the said United Stales ; for that the said brig or "vessel since the twenty-second day of March, 1794, was built, fitted, equipped, loaded, or otherwise prepared within a port or place of the said United Stales, or caused to sail from a port or place of the said United States, by a citizen or citizens of the said United States, or a foreigner, or other persons coming into, or residing in the same, either as master, factor, or owner of the said brig or vessel for the purpose of carrying on trade or traffic in slaves to a foreign country; and also for that the said brig or vessel since the day and year last afore* said, was built, equipped, loaded or otherwise prepáred within a port or place of the said United States, or caused to sail from a port or place within the said United States by a citizen or citizens of the said United States, or a foreigner or other persons coming into residing within the same, either as factory master or owner of the said brig or vessel, for the purpose of procuring .from a foreign kingdom,, place or country, the inhabitants of such kingdom, place or country, to be transported into a foreign place or country, port or place to be disposed of and sold as slaves,' in violation of a certain act of Congress of the said United States, passed tl\e,2ád March, 1794, entitled « An act to.prohibit the carrying on the slave-trade from the United States to any foreign place or country. Also for that since the 1st day of January, j 898, the said brig or vessel was built, fitted, equipped, loaded or otherwise prepared in some port or place within the jurisdiction of the said United States, or caused to sad from some port or place within the said United States by some citizen or citizens of the said United States, or some other person for the purpose of procuring negroes, mulattoes, or persons of color from some foreign kingdom, place or country, to be transported to some port or place within the jurisdiction of the said United States to be held, sold, or disposed of as slaves, or. to be held to service or labor, in violation of a certain act of Congress of the United States, passed the second day of March, in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred, and seven, entitled « An act to prohibit the importation of slaves into any port or place-within the jurisdiction of the U. States from and after the first day of January, in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and eight.” Wherefore the said United States, by Thomas Parker, their attorney aforesaid^ j)ray the advice and opinion of this honorable Court in the premises, and that on due proof of the allegations aforesaid, the said brig or Vessel, her tackle, apparel, furniture anil other ’appurtenances, may be decreed and adjudged as forfeited to them , the said United States, and that such proceedings may be had thereon as are agreeable to law and justice, and the style, usage, and practice of this honorable Court.”
«THOMAS PARKER.
Opinion of the Court
Primary OpinionThe Court, after taking time to consider, directed the following sentence to be entered.
“ This cause came oh to be heard on the transcript « of the record and was argued by counsel, on consideration whereof, it is the opinion .of the Court, that the «libel is too imperfectly drawn, p found a sentence of con- *< demnation thereon. The sentence of the said Circuit « Court is therefore reversed, and the. couse remanded « to the said Circuit Court, with directions to admit thp “ libel to be amended.”
The same point was .also decided at this term, in the cases of- the schooner Hoppet — the schooner Enteipricse~rthe ship Emily, and the scliooner Ann.