SCOTUS-Cases.net

Caze v. Baltimore Insurance

11 U.S. 358 1813-02-24 1,594 Words
Full Case Caption
CAZE AND RICHAUD v. THE BALTIMORE INSURANCE COMPANY
Official & Parallel Citations
7 Cranch 358 · 11 U.S. 358 · 3 L. Ed. 370
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 11 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

CAZE AND RICHAUD v. THE BALTIMORE INSURANCE COMPANY.

Absent....Tom>, J.

The underwriters upon a cargo are not liable for ^rataitiheriTto the owner óf 6^ vessel, owneFof the cargo insured, cargo were the «íto^he u«iderwriters as byujem a¿nd cepted, the PaM,>tlse demnedTrespro„eedsofthe cargo paid over tó the underwriters. Freight pro the owner oF the cargo voiuntarily agree receive it aplace short dLífnatíon"^

ERROR to the Circuit Court for the district of Maryland in an action of inebitatus assxonvpsit for freight of goods’by the ship Hamilton from Bordeaux to Halifax.

In the Court below a case was agreed by the parties, which was in substance as follows.

On the 28th of July, 1805, Mr. John Ifucornean,' Bordeaux, the agent of the Plaintiffs, shipped for them, there, on their account,' onboard the ship' Hamilton, which they, were owners, a cargo of the value of g> 22,986 on a voyage from Bordeaux to Mew York where the-Plaintiffs resided. On the voyage she was captured by a British vessel of war and carried into Halifax, where the ship and cargo were condemned. Within due time after the Plaintiffs heard of the capture, they abandoned as for a total loss to the Defendants who cepted the abandonment and paid the. amount insured. ■

Opinion of the Court — Story, J.

Primary Opinion

Story, J.

delivered the opinion of the Court as follows ;

The present action is brought to recover freight pro rata itineris, under the following circumstances:

The Plaintiffs were the owners of the ship Hamilton and cargo, and effected insurance of her cargo on a voyage from Bordeaux to New York. The sum of g 11,000 was underwritten by the Defendants — the sum of g 10,090' at Philadelphia, and the residue of the value of the cargo (gl986,) was left uninsured. During the Voyage the ship and cargo were captured, carried into Halifax, and there condemned. The Plaintiffs abandoned to the underwriters and received payment for a total loss. An appeal from the sentence of condemnation was interposed and the sentence finally reversed, and the proceeds of the cargo, which had been previously sold by order of Court, were paid over to the underwriters in proportion to the sums underwritten by them respectively.

We are all of opinion that the Plaintiffs are not entitled to recover in the present action.

In the first place the Court are satisfied that, as between the insured and the underwriter on the cargo of a Ship, the latter is in no case responsible for the payment Of freight, whether there be an abandonment or not. It is a charge on the cargo against which he does not undertake to indemnify the owner.; and if authority be necessary to support the position, it is fully borne but by the doctrine of lord Mansfield in Baillie v. Modigliani, Marshall, 728.

in the next place we'arc all of opinion that no freight whatsoever was, under the circumstances of this case, du'e. Freight; .in general, is not due unless the voyage be. performed. Here the ship and cargo never arrived at their port of .destination, and of course the whole freight could not be due. Was a pro rata freight due ? We think'not. The whole class of cases resting on the authority of Luke v. Lyde (2 Barr. 882.) proceed on the ground that there is a voluntary acceptance of the goods themselves at an intermediate port; and not, as in the present case, a compulsive receipt from th,e hands of the admiralty after capture and condemnation, and ultimate restoration upon the appeal. There is, in our judgment, no equity to support such a claim; and although it receive countenance from some remarks incidentally thrown out in Baillie, v. Modigliani, the current of more recent authority, as well as of principle, clearly points the other vray.

It may be further added that as between the insured and the underwriter the existence of a lien on the for freight does not vary the legal responsibility of the. underwriter on such cargo after an abandonment.

The judgment of the Circuit Court is affirmed with costs.

Cited By Later Decisions (3)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).