Dunlop v. Munroe
Syllabus & Case Posture
DUNLOP v. MUNROE.
Present....ML the Judges.
When the Issue is taken glee" the°' port-master not competent (ogive in eir'^Tofhls”3' distant.U3 When it is nh^e p past-Waster, for the ÍSfef'Sunts! the '"pleadings must be mude to *he case” to! his liability Msuiífrom his own neglect in the discharge” tooffice't,S ln bitier'to mafo; a.i>ost■fw^egtiganc'-, must appear std'by the nucnce of the negligence, ra*motbe' w-C ven that om> jrirtracrioni'11 frbm the postTstor snotS1 set'of wrjtt™ instnictions,
ERROR to the Circuit Court fur tiie district of Columbia, sitting'at Washington, in,an action wherein James and John Dunlop were Plaintiffs, and Thomas Munroe, the deputy post-master at Washington, was Defendant ' rteienu.uit.
The declaration after having, been several times .amended, contained nine counts.
L The first count was as follows — Thomas Munroe, late of .Washington county, gentleman, was attached to answer unto James Dunlop-¿nd John- Dunlop in a plea of trespass on the case, &c. whereupon the said James an¿. j0j,y1} by Francis S. -Key, their attorney complain, that whereas, by the laws of. the United States of America, relative to the post-office establishment of the United -States, and of the post-roads within the United States, it was enacted, that there should be established, ^16 sca^ °* the government of the United States, a general post-office, under the direction of a post-master !?eTierat> "¿fed that post-offices should be established; and that post-masters should be appointed by the said postni¿Ster general, at all such pláces as should-appear to hifio expedient, on the post-roads which then, wei;e, or might thereafter he established, and the carriage of the on all such post-roads provided for; and that every post-m aster, so appointed by the said post-master general, should keep an office, in which one or more persons should attend for the purpose of performing the duties thereof; and a post-road was directed to be established -Passamaquaddy, in the'district of Maine, to St. Mary’s, in Georgia, within the said United States; and í-hOjcity of Philadcl]>hia, in the State of Pennsylvania, antHhe city of Washington, in the district of Columbia, town of Petersburg, in the state of Virginia, were -places through which the said post-road was dirented by -law to pass. And whereas in pursuance of the said laws, a general'post-office was established at the seat of government of the' United States, under the direction of á post-master general, duly appointed and qualified, and a post-road established within the U. Slates from Passamaquaddy, in the district of Maine aforesaid, to St. Mary’s, in Georgia aforesaid ; ,and the said city of Philadelphia, and the, said city of Washington, and the said town of Petersburgh, were places through which the said road did pass, and post-offices .were, duty established at the said places, so as aforesaid on the said post-road, by.the said poist-inaster general; and post-masters by him duly appointed and qualified to attend to the duties of the said post-offices, and the carriage of the mail of theU. States'on the said post-roád provided.for by the said post-master, general agreeably to law: and the said Thomas Munroe was, bj; the,said post-master general, duly appointed and qualified the post-master at the said office, so as aforesaid established át the said city of Washington on the said post-road, and between the city of Philadelphia and the town of Petersburgh aforesaid, also on the said post-road, and as such was bound to attend to and perform all the duties, thereof, and to receive, make up, and distribute and forward the mails of the said United States, and all the. letters and packets contained therein which should arrive or come. to Ms said post-office, so by him kept.as aforesaid at the said city of Washington,, to all such places on the said post road to which the same were directed, and addressed ; and the said Thomas so being, as aforesaid, postmaster at the said post-office, so as aforesaid lawfully established at the said city of Washington, on the post-road so as aforesaid also lawfully established, and post-offices being, also, in like manner, lawfully established *£t the- said city of Philadelphia, and the said town of Petersburgh, on the said post road, and post-masters duly appointed and qualified,, and attending to the duties of the said post-offices, on. the thirtieth day of July, in the year eighteen hundred and six, the said James and John being' possessed of á large sum of money, to wit: the sum of two thousand dollars current money of the." United States of their own proper money, and being so possessed thereof, on .the same day and year, did enclose 'the same in bank notes by means of their agents in that particular, (a ¡certain1 Walker and Kennedy) in a letter sealed* and directed to the said James and John at Petersburgh, in Virginia aforesaid^ on the post-road aforesaid, and the said sum of, money, sb sealed and on-closed ip said letter so directed, did place in the post-office in the said city of Philadelphia, so as aforesaid established on. the said post-road,- tobe forwarded.oh said poet road, in the mail of the United States to the said town of Petersbugh on the post-road aforesaid, and the said letter, directed . as foreasid, and the money in bank notes as aforesaid, to the said amount, enclosed in the same, were- accordingly, by.-the said post-master at Philadelphia, apd from the office there established as aforesaid oh the said post road, sent on and forwarded in the mail of the U. States, on the day and year aforesaid5 •• and did afterwards, to wit: on the first day of August, in tire year aforesaid, .arrive at the post-office of the' said Thomas, postmaster, as aforesaid, in the said city, of Washington, on the said post-road, in the mail of the United States, on the route to the post-office at Peters-burgh aforesaid, op the post-road aforesaid, and was, Op-the day and year last mentioned, at the county of 'Washington aforesaid, receivéd by.the said Thomas lobe by him sent on and forwarded in the mail of the United States/on the said post-road, to the said James and John, at Petersburgb, to whom the same was directed and addressed ;■ yet the said Thomas, regardless of his said duty as postmaster, and wholly neglecting the same, did not send on the said letter, and the sum- of money contained and enclosed, in the same, to the said town of Petersbugh, on .the said postroád, in the mail of the United States, to the said James aiid John'to whom the •same w^s. directed, as it-was'his duty to do; but the •same letter and the said sum of money therein contained as aforesaid, were fraudulently and improperly secreted# withheld, and taken, in the said post-office, at the city of Washington- aforesaid, by the said Thomas, or some Other person employed by him, in his said office, so that the said J ames and John were prevented from receiving the same, and Ike same letter, and sum of money, have been tvholly lost to the said Plaintiffs,
Opinion of the Court — Johnson, J.
Primary OpinionJohnson, J.
delivered, the opinion of the Court as follows :
it is necéssary +o dissipate the cloud of pleading in Which this case is enveloped, in order to form a distinct idea of the questions intended to be brought to the view of the Couii, below.
The object is to charge the post-master with the loss of money sent by mail; and the points, which the exceptions are intended to make; are, how far he is liable for his own act or neglect,, how. far for the acts or neglect of .his'- assistants, and what evidence shall be sufficient to support the Plaintiff’s action.
, But unfortunately, as not unfrequently happens in this complex and injudicious mode of conducting a suit, with all the clerical skill displayed by counsel in multiplying their counts and pointing their bills of exceptions, the principal questions are really, at last, not brought to the view of this Court.
On the first and second exception it is unnecessary to make any remark, as they are admitted to apply to counts which the evidence did not support and have bepn, in fact, abandoned.
The third, exception is intended to raise the question how far a post-master is liable for the neglect of his assistants; but, connected witli the pleadings, it presents-another and a very different question, to wit, whether, whén tíie issue is taken upon the neglect of the postmaster himself, it is competent to give in evidence, neglect in the assistant acting under him. Now the distinction between the relation of a post-master to his sworn assistant acting under him, and between master ■and servant generally, has long been settled; and although the latter relation might sanction the admission of such evidence', we are unanimously, of ,opinion that, if it is intended to charge a post-master, for the negligence of his assistants, the pleadings must be made up according to the case; and his liability then will only result from, his own neglect in not properly superintending the. discharge of their duties in his office.
: In the fourth exception, the only difference between the opinion prayed for and that given, is, that the Court require the loss to be a, consequence of not forwardipg the letter described in the declaration. Now, in justice to the correctness of the. Plaintiffs’ counsel, this Court hope that they meant nothing more than what the Court conceded; for, certainly, if the loss was not a consequence of the state of things made out in the evidence, they were not entitled to recover.
On the fifth exception it is only necessary to remark, that if the Court below erred at all, it was in conceding too much to the prayer of the Plaintiff. An entry on the post-bill is by no means conclusive evidence of the transmission of a letter, for, it may still never have been put into the mail, or may have been stolen in its passage.
The sixth exception is equally untenable. _ The instructions of the post-master general spoke for themselves. If the one superseded or rescinded the other, the evidence was to.,be sought for by .comparing them together.
And the seventh exception affords the Court an opportunity to remark how much more conducive to the purposes of justice it would be to substitute special ver dicts, and demurrers to evidence, for the tedious and embarrassing practice of the Court from which this case comes up.- It is a fact that this bill of exceptions claims a right of rerovery without stating any loss or damage whatever. The opinion prayed for was, that if the jury believed the various facts therein detailed, then it is incumbent on the Defendant to. make out a just, reasonable and sufficient excuse for omitting to forward the letter described. But, unless an individual has sustained some loss or damage by an omission of that kind, why should the post-master be held to make out a defence ? Each bill of exceptions must be considered as presenting a distinct, substantive case; and it is on the evidence stated in itself alone that the Court’is to decide. We cannot go beyond it and collect other facts which must have neen in the mind of the party, and the insertion of which in this bill of exceptions could alone have sanctioned the opinion as prayed for.
Upon the whole, the judgment below must be affirmed.