Maryland Insurance v. Wood
Syllabus & Case Posture
THE MARYLAND INSURANCE COMPANY. v. WOOD.
• - Mr? Merrv to the secretary isd^S’April? 1804, extend: fandof Curra" goa, the of-der óf the lords cóttinus'Rduers ortlieadmipuU ty of the sth of re"pSÍ*te blockade0 of tíwdSe & a °I,e‘ .
ERROR to the Circuit Court for ■ the district of Maryland, in an action, of covenant’on a policy upon the schooner William and Mary “ at and from Balti- “ moi‘e to kaguira, with liberty of one other neighbor- “ ing port, and at and from them or either of them back “^0 Baltimore” — “ Warranted by .the assured to be an ^American bottom, proof of which to be required in « the United States only.”
The former judgment of the Circuit Court, in this case’ having been reversed (see ante, vol. 6, p. 29,) and the cause remanded for a new trial, the verdict and judgmen:fc Wftt’e aSain in favor of the original Plaintiff. The Defendants, took only one bill of exceptions which stated the execution of the policy, the sailing of the vessel with proper documents as ííñ American bottom from Baltimore on the 8th of March, 1805, upon the voyage insured; her arrival, off Laguira .on the 24th of the. same month, where’ she. remained three days laying off and.on, vainly endeavoring to obtain permission to enter the port, and orf the 31st sailed towards .the port of Amsterdam, in the island of Curracoa, by the direct and accustomed route, with a view and intention of ascertaining by enquiry of British .ships of war, or other vessels, whether the port of Amsterdam was then in a state of blockade, and to enter it if it should be blockaded, but if jt should be blockaded, not to attempt to enter it, hut to proceed to St.-Thomas’s or Porto Rico. That Amsterdam was a neighboring port to Laguira, being distant about 147 miles. ■ That when she approached Amsterdam, being distant about 30 Añiles, theinastcr discovered a Brilish vessel at the distance of 21 miles, whereupon he altered the course of the schooner, and stood diroctly towards the British vessel for the purpose of inquiring whether Amsterdam was still in a state of blockade; that while so standing for the British vessel, which was a frigate then actually supporting the blockade of the port of Amsterdam, the schooner was captured by the frigate and sent into Jamaica, and there condemned for breach of the blockade of Hie port of Amsterdam, whereby she was wholly lost to the Plaintiff. That on the IGth of May, 1805, the Plaintiff having received intelligence of the capture, abandoned the vessel in due time to the unslet writers, who refused to accept the abandonment.
That on the 27th of October, 1803, the .government of the United States made to the British government, through its charge d’affairs in the .United States, a representation on the subject of a blockade, then recently notified, of the Islands of Martinique, and Gaudalopej which representation is set forth at large in the bill of exceptions, being a letter from -Mr, Madison, then Secretary of state, to Mr. Thornton, the British charge d’affairs, dated the. 27th of October, 1803.
That on the 5th of January, 1804, the British government, in consequence of that representation, issued an order to its commanding naval officer in the West Indies and to its Courts of vice admiralty tlierej relative to the blockade of Martinique and Gaudalope,* which order is as follows :
Opinion of the Court — Livingston, J.
Primary OpinionLivingston, J.
Afterwards delivered the opinion of the Court in writing, as follows:
It is the opinion of the.Court, that the communication of the British minister to the American government on the tzth of April, 1804, relative to the blockade of Cur-' raeoa, furnished a sufficient excuse for the assured's pro-. ceeding towards that Island for the purpose of enquiring as to its continuance, and that his doing so was no violation of his neutrality.
The Court does not mean to be understood as giying any opinion , on the effect of such conduct if no such communication had been made.
The judgment of the Circuit Court is affirmed with costs.