SCOTUS-Cases.net

Mutual Assurance Society v. Korn

11 U.S. 396 1813-03-03 1,087 Words
Full Case Caption
THE MUTUAL ASSURANCE SOCIETY v. KORN AND WISEMILLER
Official & Parallel Citations
7 Cranch 396 · 11 U.S. 396 · 3 L. Ed. 383
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 11 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

THE MUTUAL ASSURANCE SOCIETY v. KORN AND WISEMILLER.

•/i&sent....Washington, J.

The. propriaéfs of buildmgs m Alexandria, insured by the society, thereact°ofd^ isembiy of ginia passed in subsequent018 regulations of pay San'etaád¡tionai puemiof hazard ac-newinreguia‘e lions of isos":

ERROR to the Circuit Court for the district of Columbia, sitting at Alexandria.

The Mutual Assurance Society against fire> &c. was incorporated by anact of the legislature of Virginia in

According to the original plan of- the institution the houses in the towns and country were blended together one general mass, and were mutually pledged to each other, to make good, the losses which might he respecsustained by fire.

Opinion of the Court — Johnson, J.

Primary Opinion

Johnson, J.

delivered the .opinion of the Court as follows:

In the case decided between. Atkinson and these Plaintiffs, February term, 1810, the question arose on the construction of the 7th section of the act of 1805, and the additional premium in that case was imposed upon a re-valuation without relation to a change in the rates of premium, but resulting from the increased valuation.

In this case the sum demanded arises from the changes made in the rates .of premium, arising from a variation of risk $ to equalize which the 8th article of the present rules of the society requires an additional per centage to be paid by the present members of the company, in conformity to what is to be imposed upon su,bsequent applicants for insurance. And it is contended that the contract being complete between the parties, the insurers cannot add to the consideration to be for insurance. In general this doctrine is unquestionably correct, but peculiar circumstances except this from ordinary cases. This subject was considered in the quoted case decided between these same parties in February, 1810. It is there laid down, and on reflection we are confirmed in the opinion, that in the capacity of an individual of the body corporate the Defendants are bound by the bylaws of the society as far as is consistent with the nature of its institution.

This case is within the 4th section of the 8th article of those by-laws, and therefore the judgment below ought to have b.een for the Plaintiffs.

Judgment reversed.

Cited By Later Decisions (1)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).