SCOTUS-Cases.net

Wells v. U. States

11 U.S. 22 1812-02-20 1,400 Words
Full Case Caption
BRIG JAMES WELLS v. THE U. STATES
Official & Parallel Citations
7 Cranch 22 · 11 U.S. 22 · 3 L. Ed. 256
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 11 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

BRIG JAMES WELLS v THE U. STATES.

Msent..,.Marshall, chief justice,

In eases of admiralty juriseridence'wiii be admitted iñ forAatpur"d pose acommission may issue,

yhe evidence of that nebestion of the. toSS°yeiy clear and pos•ltive-

THIS was an appeal from a sentence of the Cireuit court which'affirmed that of the District Court of Connecticut, restoring the Cargo but condemning the brig James Wells, an American registered1 vessel, for a violation of the 5d section of the embargo act of Januayy ¿g08, in making a voyage to St. Bartholomews under a clearance for the port of - SL Mary's, in the state: 0j Qeorgia. The excuse suggested by the claimant of vessel was stress of weather. He stated in his claim and answer, that the vessel laden with 1272 barrels of ’flour» sailed from New York on the 26th of February,, 1808, cleared and bound for SL Mary’s, with abona fide intention of going there, and without any intent of going to any foreign place. But that by contrary winds and stress of weather and the leaky condition of the vessel? he was compelled against his will (he being owner and. supercargo) and against the will of the captain and crew* to go to, and enter the port of Gustavia, in the island of St, Bartholomews, in the West Indies, where he was obliged by the leaky and shattered condition of the vessel, to unlade the cargo, which was greatly damaged,, and he could , not afterwards obtain permission to carry it away again, but was compelled to sell it there,

The evidence tin the part of the Claimant tended to prove that after the vessel got to sea, and the weather was rough she leaked considerably in her upper works, so that in bad weather they had to keep two pumps going at the rate of three or four hundred every half hour, that after being six days' at sea, it was judged “best for the preservation of their lives as well as “for the safety of vessel and cargo, to bear away for ‘f any of the West India Islands”....that when they arrived at St. Bartholomews, part of the flour was damaged, and they were obliged to unlade the vessel to have her surveyed and repaired. That the governor of the island had prohibited the exportation of provisions and would not permit them to take away their cargo.

Opinion of the Court — Washington J.

Primary Opinion

Washington J.

delivered the opinion of the Court as follows:

That the law under which this prosecution is founded, has been, prima facie, violated, is admitted; and it becomes absolutely necessary for the defendant, if he would excuse the breach, to bring ■ himself within the “exception ma/de for his benefit, not by doubtful testimony, but by such as shall leave no reasonable doubt of -the sincerity of his exertions to proceed to some port in the United States, and the danger or apparent impossibility of doing so.

.That the vessel, shortly after ..leaving New York, leaked considerably is proved;-but it is also proved that the leak was in her upper works; that she could be freed, and, by great exertions, was kept free of water.

It is clearly proved that, after a sail of six days, she fcore away for the West-Indies, and the danger of continuing on the coast is indirectly stated, though no where positively affirmed.

But it is not proved by a single witness that an exertion was made to gain a port of the United States, or that the attempt, if it had been made, would, in the opinion of one person, on board, have failed or been attended with danger. Nor are the state of the winds, or the latitade and longitude of the vessel when she bore awáy, given in. evidence so as to enable the Court to judge, In short, had the original destination been to the West-Indies, and this known to the crew, it would be difficult to fix perjury upon any one of those who have given evidence in this cause.

In such a case, where no presumption can, or ought to be made in favor of the owner of the vessel, and with so strong a temptation as he had to violate the law — her condemnation is inevitable.

Sentence affirmed, with costs„

Cited By Later Decisions (1)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).