Wilson v. Koontz
Syllabus & Case Posture
WILSON v. KOONTZ.
Fresent,...Ml the Judges.
The DefentAciimenT U chancery in "Virginia may tuteof limta-. tions without answer
A Defendantwho removes fromonecoun- ¡„ vhg1nt!,h<is not .thereby f^enl)ea(iiri1 tíiTactoHimf ™'.^s ^ beenf'by such removal, a^“ea”y0^e;)b, structcd m blil?s¡ns. or hi^S”S
THIS was an appeal.from the decree of the Circuit Court for tjie district of Columbia, which dismissed the Complainant’s bill in. equity.
Wilson filed a bill in equity, in the nature of an attachment in chancery, against Koontz, surviving partne,> of Koontz and Ober, as principal debtor, and Thomas Irvine and Joseph Mandevilie as garnishees. It stated that Koontz, a resident of Virginia, as surviving partner of the firm of Koontz and Ober, was indebted to the Plaintiff by note, in the sum of 1,261 dollars, and had in the hands of Thomas Irvine and Joseph vil le goods and effects which were liable to be attached for the payment Of the debt; and that unless he could make them liable by the intervention of the- Court' be-, low, he would be without any means of recovering his debt. In tender consideration whereof,, and for as much as he had no remedy at law, and could only subject the effects and money in the hands of Irvine and Maudeville to the payment of his debt by means of a Court of equity, he prays a discovery, and a uecree that Koontz may pay the debt, and that Irvine and M andeville may be restrained from paying away the effects in their hands, and thatjthey may be applied to the payment of the debt, and for general relief.
Opinion of the Court — Marshall. Ch. J.
Primary OpinionMarshall. Ch. J.
delivered the opinion of the Court to the following effect:
This is'a suit in chancery, and the. Defendant pleads the act of limitations. The Plaintiff by his replication attempts to bring the case within the exception contained in the 14th section of that act5. but it seems essen-" tial, under that section, that the Complainant should have been actually defeated or obstructed ip bringing his action by the removal of the Defendant. ' There is no evidence of his intention of bringing bis action sooner than he did, or that he was delayed by the Defendant’s removal from the county. The Court is therefore of opinion that the circumstance,of removal is not sufficient to take the case out of the statute,
. It is objected, that the plea* of the statute of limitations is not good unless the Defendant answer also and deny the debt, or aver it to be paid. But if this be a valid objection, it ought to have been takeri at the time of offering the plea, and before the issue was joined, I£ is now too late.
If it be a good objection in cases within the general jurisdiction of a Court of equity, yet it is not valid in a case like the present' which is really á case at law as - between the present parties.
The Court is of opinion that the plea is á good-bar, and that the decree should be affirmed.