Stewart v. Hoyt's Executors
Syllabus & Case Posture
STEWART & Another v. HOYT’S EXECUTORS.
APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF WISCONSIN.
Argaed April 9th, 1884.
Decided April 21st, 1884.
Contract — Lease—Railroad.
By a lease from one railroad corporation of its railroad to another railroad corporation, subject to a previous mortgage, the lessee covenanted to pay as renta certain proportion of the gross earnings, and to state accounts semiannually, and further covenanted, if the rent for any six months should be insufficient to pay the interest due at the end of the six months on the mortgage bonds, then to advance a sufficient sum to take up, and to take up the balance of the coupons for such interest; and it was agreed that for all sums so advanced the lessee should have a lien before all other liens except the mortgage. Eighteen months later, after the lessee had accordingly paid and taken up some coupons, and had declined to take up others, on account of the refusal of the lessor to accept in payment of rent coupons so taken up, the two 'corporations executed a supplemental agreement, by which, in lieu of the rent reserved in the lease, and of all advances of money'to take up coupons, the lessee covenanted to pay, and the lessor to accept, as rent, a larger proportion of the gross earnings, “all accounts being settled exactly, and all liabilities and obligations between the two companies being adjusted and discharged by and upon the semi-annual statements provided in said lease;” the lessor released the lessee from any obligation to make future advances of money to take up coupons, and from liability for any previous neglect to make such'advances, and from any obligation to pay money in the nature of rent and advances, except the proportion of the gross earnings stipulated in the supplemental agreement; an¿ all the provisions of the lease, except as so modified, were ratified and confirmed, and “ all causes of action for breach of any agreement therein contained,” which had arisen since its execution, were mutually waived and released. The lessee afterwards paid rent computed according to the supplemental agreement. Held, That any claim of the lessee against the lessor, or against the mortgaged property, for money paid to take up coupons, was released and discharged.
Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice Gray
Primary OpinionMr. Justice Gray
delivered the opinion of the court. He stated the facts in the foregoing language, and continued:
The petitioners contend that for the sum paid to take up coupons in accordance with the provisions of the lease of November 8th, 1873, they have a claim against the lessor, and a lien upon the proceeds of the sale of the mortgaged property, equal to those which the original owners of those coupons had.
But this court concurs in opinion with the' Circuit Court that, if the lessee ever had such a claim and lien, they were released by the supplemental agreement of June 1st, 1875, and the payment of rent, and the adjustment of semi-annual accounts, in accordance therewith. By this agreement, the provisions of the original lease Avere confirmed and ratified,’ “except so far as are herein expressly modified or changed;” the proportion of gross earnings to be paid as rent was increased ; all accounts betiveen the parties Avere to be adjusted and discharged by and upon the semi-annual statements; the lessor released the lessee from all obligation to'make future advances, and from all liability for past neglect to make advances, to take up coupons; and each party released the other from all causes of action Avhich had arisen for breach of any agreement in the original lease. Any obligation of the lessor to reimburse to the lessee money paid by the latter to take up coupons, arose under an agreement in the original lease and Avas one of the obligations adjusted and discharged by and upon the semi-annual statements. The intention of the supplemental agreement, as appears upon its face, Avas to adjust all existing controversies betAveen the parties, by agreeing to pay and receive an increased rate of rent, and by mutually releasing all existing obligations and liabilities, .including, on the one side, the lessee’s obligation to take up coupons in the future, and its liability for neglect to take them up in the past, and, on the other side, the- lessor’s obligation and liability to the lessee by reason of coupons already taken up by the latter. The parol evidence introduced by the petitioners at the hearing, if competent in laAV, Avas quite insufficient in fact, to control or vary the meaning of the Avritten instrument.
Decree affirmed.