SCOTUS-Cases.net

Davis Sewing Machine Co. v. Richards

115 U.S. 524 1885-12-07 1,377 Words
Full Case Caption
DAVIS SEWING MACHINE COMPANY v. RICHARDS & Another
Official & Parallel Citations
115 U.S. 524 · 29 L. Ed. 480 · 6 S. Ct. 173
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 115 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

DAVIS SEWING MACHINE COMPANY v. RICHARDS & Another.

IN ERROR TO THE SUPREME COURT OF THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA.

Argued November 10, 11, 1885.

Decided December 7, 1885.

An agreement in writing between a manufacturing corporation and its agent for a certain district, by which it agreed to sell /him its goods at certain prices, and he agreed to sell the goods and payi Jt those prices, was signed by the agent. A guaranty of his future performance of his agreement was signed by another'person on the same day, and delivered by the guarantor to the agent. The agreement and guaranty were delivered by the agent to an attorney of the corporation, who two days afterwards wrote under the guaranty his certificate of the sufficiency of the guarantor, and forwarded the agreement and guaranty to the corporation, which thereupon signed the agreement, but gave no notice to the guarantor of ils signature of the agreement or acceptance of the guaranty. Held, That the contract of guaranty was not complete, and the guarantor was not liable for the price of goods sold by the corporation to the agent and not paid for by him.

This was an action, brought in tfyd Supreme Court of the District of Columbia, upon a guaranty' of thq performance by one John W. Poler of a contract under seal, dated December 17, 1872, between him and the plaintiff corporation, by which it was agreed that all sales of sewing machines which the corporation 'should make to him should be upon certain terms and conditions, the principal of which were that Poler should use all reasonable efforts to introduce, supply and sell the machines of the corporation, at not. less, than its regular retail prices, throughout’the District of Columbia and the counties of Prince George and Montgomery in the State of Maryland, and should pay all indebtedness by account, note, indorsement or otherwise, which should -arise from him to. the- corporation under the contract, and should not engage in the sale of sewing machines of any other manufacture; and that the corporation, during the continuance of the agency, should sell its machines to him at a certain discount, and receive payment therefor in certain manner; and that either party might terminate the agency at pleasure.

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice Gray

Primary Opinion

Mr. Justice Gray

delivered the opinion of the court. After, stating the facts in the language above reported^ he continued:

The decision, of this case depends , upon the application of the rules of law stated in the opinion in the recent case of Davis v. Wells, 104 U. S. 159, in which the earlier decisions of this court upon the subject are reviewed.

Those rules may be summed up as follows: A contract of guaranty, like every other contract, can only be made by the mutual assent of the parties. If the guaranty is signed by the guarantor at the request of the other party, or if the latter’s agreement to accept is contemporaneous with the guaranty, or if the receipt from him of a valuable consideration, however small, is acknowledged in the guaranty, the mutual assent is proved, and the delivery of the guaranty to him or for his use completes the contract. But if the guaranty is signed by the guarantor, without any previous request of the other party, and in his absence, for no consideration moving between them except future advances to be made to the principal debtor, the guaranty is in. legal effect an offer or proposal on the part of the guarantor, needing an acceptance by the other party to complete the contract.

The case at bar belongs to the latter class. There is no evidence of any request from the plaintiff corporation to the guarantors, or of any consideration moving from it and received or acknowledged by them at the time of their signing the guaranty. The general words at the beginning of the guaranty, “ value received,” without stating from w-hom, are quite as consistent with a consideration received by the guarantors from the principal debtor only. The certificate of the sufficiency of the guarantors; written- by the plaintiff’s attorney under the guaranty, bears date two days later than' the guaranty itself.- The plaintiff’s original contract with the principal debtor was not executed by the plaintiff until after that. The guarantors had no notice that their sufficiency had been approved, or that their guaranty had been accepted, or even that the original contract had been1 executed or assented to by the plaintiff,--until long afterwards, when payment was demanded of them for goods supplied by the plaintiff to the principal, debtor. Judgment affirmed.

Precedents Cited (1)

Cited By Later Decisions (3)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).