SCOTUS-Cases.net

Ex parte Phœnix Insurance

117 U.S. 367 1886-03-29 941 Words
Full Case Caption
EX PARTE PHŒNIX INSURANCE COMPANY & Others
Official & Parallel Citations
117 U.S. 367 · 29 L. Ed. 923 · 6 S. Ct. 772
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 117 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

EX PARTE PHŒNIX INSURANCE COMPANY & Others.

ORIGINAL.

Argued March 22, 1886.

Decided March 29, 1886.

Distinct decrees against distinct parties, on distinct canses of action, or on a single cause of action in which there are distinct liabilities, cannot be joined to give this court jurisdiction on^appeal.

Rule to show cause why a writ of mandamus should not issue to the .judges of the Circuit Court of the United States for the District of Yermont, commanding them to allow an appeal from decrees and rulings made by that court in a suit in equity, in which the petitioners were respondents, and Robert Fitton and Helen M. Fitton his wife were complainants. The relief sought in the bill was the discovery of certain policies of insurance made by the Phcenix Insurance Company, the Guardian Fire and Life Insurance Company, the North British Mercantile Insurance Company, and the Commercial Union Assurance Company through their agent, and that the defendants might be decreed to pay the complainant the sum of $12,000 insured by the-policies, the property insured having been destroyed by fire. Sundry proceedings in the suit were set forth in the petition, among which,were that issues of fact were submitted to a jury on the law side of the court and a verdict thereon was had- in favor of the complainants ; and that thereupon a master found that the damages sustained by complainants were greater than the amount demanded- in the bill; and then the petition made the following allegations :

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Chief Justice "Waite

Primary Opinion

Mr. Chief Justice "Waite

delivered the opinion of the court.

The rule is well settled that distinct decrees against distinct parties on distinct causes of action, or on a single cause of action in which there are distinct liabilities, cannot be joined to give this court jurisdiction on appeal. Seaver v. Bigelows, 5 Wall. 208; Ex parte Baltimore & Ohio Railroad Co., 106 U. S. 5; Schwed v. Smith, 106 U. S. 188; Farmers’ Loan and Trust Co. v. Turner, 106 U. S. 265, 270; Adams Crittenden, 106 U. S. 576; Hawley v. Fairbanks, 108 U. S. 543; Fourth National Bank v. Stout, 113 U. S. 684; Stewart v. Dunham, 115 U. S. 61, 64. This is such a case. The suit was brought on a single instrument, by which, as it was adjudged, an agent of the several insurance companies named bound them severally, each for its proportionate share of one-fourth, to insure the property of Mrs. Helen M. Eitton for $12,000, and the decree is against .each company separately for its separate obligation under this instrument, to wit, $3433.50, and no more. The bill alleged the separate liability of each company, and prayed in substance, for decrees against them severally for tbe proportion assumed by each in tbe contract. Each company answered separately, all setting up the same defences.

Under these circumstances it was right for the Circuit Court to refuse the allowance of an appeal, and

The petition for a mandamus is consequently denied.

Precedents Cited (8)

Cited By Later Decisions (4)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).