Francis v. Flinn
Syllabus & Case Posture
FRANCIS & Others v. FLINN.
APPEAL PROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OP THE UNITED STATES POR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OP LOUISIANA.
Argued April 20, 1886. —
Decided May 10, 1886.
A bill in equity -which alleges that complainant, a citizen of Florida, is part owner with other parties named, citizens of Louisiana, of a steam pilot-boat, on which are employed branch pilots duly licensed; that respondents had confederated together to destroy said business and property by publications in newspapers, by instituting suits, by seeking injunctions, and in divers other ways; and that they had agreed together not to do business as branch pilots with any persons other than those included in the “confederation”' —and which prays for a perpetual inj unction to restrain the defendant from interfering with the rights of the complainant, his pilot-boat and his business — furnishes no ground for the interposition of a court of equity, as' complainant has adequate remedies at law for each and all the acts complained of.
This was a suit in equity to restrain the defendants [appellants in this court] from doing certain things charged against them intended to injure the plaintiff, and destroy his property and business. The bill alleged that he was a citizen of Florida, and brought the bill against Richard Francis, individually and as agent for others, and "W. T. Levine and thirty-seven others, who were named, and who were citizens of Louisiana. It set forth that he was one eighth owner of the steam pilot-boat Mary Lee, a decked vessel of over fifty tons burden; that his interest exceeded the value of $5000 ; that she was built, and was manned and equipped, and in all respects fitted for the purposes of a pilot-boat, and for some months had been, and was then used as a pilot-boat at South Pass, known as the jetties, at one of the mouths of the Mississippi River; that by act of Congress of June 1,1874, the pass, or channel, had been since the beginning of the construction of the jetties under control of the Seci’etary of War; that the government had caused'the obstructions formerly existing in the channel, known as the bar, to be removed; that the pass was subject to no other regulations than those prescribed by the Secretary; that the plaintiff in his business of pilot had, in all respects, conformed to them; that the captain and other officers of his vessel were duly commissioned under the laws of the United States; that certain persons named Pliny Cox, George A. Falconi, and Hiram Follett were on board as branch pilots, and they acted as pilots on vessels inward and outward bound to and from the sea through the South Pass, and, as part owners of the pilot-boat, they were licensed under the laws of the United States as branch pilots for the port of New Orleans; and that as such they were entitled to pilot vessels from the sea to the Mississippi River, and from the river to the sea.
Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice Field,
Primary OpinionMr. Justice Field,
after stating the case as above reported, delivered the opinion of the court.
The bill does not state what the publications were of which the plaintiff complains, or what the divers suits instigated by the defendants were other than those mentioned, in which charges were made as to towing vessels through the pass without pilots, and as to certain persons not being branch pilots, or contracting not to serve as such. Nor does it state any of’the other. “ various and divers ways ” in which he is injured by the defendants.
The whole gist of the complaint is that the defendants do not treat the plaintiff as having a right to use his vessel as a pilot-boat, and have publicly so stated, and that some of the parties mentioned have been subjected to suits for their acts in piloting. But if this be so, the plaintiff has a full remedy for his alleged wrongs in the courts of law. They furnish no ground for the interposition of a court of equity. If the plaintiff has a right to pilot vessels with his boat through the pass and is wrongfully interfered with by the defendants or others, he can prosecute them for the wrong. If his vessel is arrested in its passage, without lawful warrant, he can bring the defendants before the courts to answer for their conduct. If his pilots are duly licensed,- and they are hindered or prevented from the exercise of their business, both he and they have the same means of redress which are afforded to every citizen whose rights are invaded and obstructed. If the publications in the newspapers are false and injurious, he can prosecute the publishers for libel. If a court of equity could interfere and use its remedy of injunction in such cases, it would draw to itself the greater part of the litigation properly belonging to courts of law.
"We think the court below should have sustained the demurrer of the defendants for want of equity in the bill. The decree must, therefore, be
Reversed, and the cause remcmded, with instructions to dismiss the bill.