South Boston Iron Co. v. United States
Syllabus & Case Posture
SOUTH BOSTON IRON COMPANY v. UNITED STATES.
APPEAL FROM THE COURT OF CLAIMS.
Argued April 8, 1886. —
Decided April 19, 1886.
H offered to the Secretary of the Navy by letter to construct new boilers for certain vessels of the Navy. The ofler was accepted at the Navy Department, by letter, and he was also thereby informed that the drawings and specifications would be furnished as soon as possible. ' A few days later he was notified to discontinue all work contracted for by him with the Department. On a suit brought in the Court of Claims for damages for nonperformance of the contract, Held, that the letters did not constitute a contract with the United States under the provisions of Rev. Stat. §§ 3744-3749.
This was a suit in the Court of Claims to recover of the United States $75,000 damages, and $143,264.06 profits, which the claimant there alleged that it had suffered, or had been deprived of, by reason of the breach of two contracts which it claimed it had made for the construction of boilers for vessels belonging to the Navy of the United States. The defendants pleaded the general issue. The only proof of the alleged contract and of the breach and claim for damages was contained in the following correspondence:
Opinion of the Court — Mr. Chief Justice Waite
Primary OpinionMr. Chief Justice Waite
delivered the opinion of the court.
In Clark v. The United States, 95 U. S. 539, it was decided that, to bind the United States, contracts by the Navy Department must be in writing, and signed by the contracting parties. Such, in the opinion of the court, was the effect of the act of June 2, 1862, 12 Stat. 411, ch. 93, now in force as §§ 3744-3747 and §§ 512-515 of the Revised Statutes. _ An effort has been made in this case to show a contract in writing, but we agree entirely with the Court of Claims that the papers relied on for that purpose are nothing more in law or in fact than the preliminary memoranda made by the parties for use in preparing a contract for execution in the form required by law. This was never done, and, therefore, the United States never became bound. Within a very few days after the memoranda were made the whole matter was abandoned by the Department, and the Iron Company has neither performed any of the work which was referred to, nor has it ever been called on to do so.
The judgment is
Affirmed.