Bignall v. Gould
Syllabus & Case Posture
BIGNALL v. GOULD.
ERROR TO THE CIECUIT COtJET . OE THE -UNITED STATES EOE THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF MISSOURI.
Submitted December 7, 1886.
Decided December 20, 1886.
' In a bond “ in the penal sum of $10,000, liquidated damages,” with condition that Certain third-persons shall within a year release the obligee from a large number of debts held by them severally., and varying from $8000 to $10 each, the sum of $10,000 is a penalty, and not liquidated damages; and in an action thereon the obligee, upon proof that hone of those debts were released by the holders'within the year, but that immediately after-wards he was discharged from all of them in bankruptcy, can recover nominal damages only.
.This was an action brought in September, 1881, by a citizen of Missouri against a citizen of New York upon the following’ bond, signed and sealed by the defendant:
Opinion of the Court — Mu. Justice '©bay,
Primary OpinionMu. Justice '©bay,
after stating tbe case as above reported, delivered the opinion of the court.
By the rules now established, at law as well as in equity, -the sum of $10,000, named in this bond, is a penalty only, and not liquidated damages. As observed by Lord Tenterden in a similar case, “whoever framed this agreement does not appear to have had any very clear idea of the distinction between a penalty and liquidated damages; for the sum ” in question “ is described in the same sentence as a penal sum and as liquidated damages.” Davies v. Penton, 6 B. & C. 216, 222 ; S. C. 9 D. & R. 369, 376. The object of the bond is to secure the obligee’s discharge from a large number of claims against him, held, by certain third persons severally, amounting in all to something like $39,000, and varying from more than $8000 to less than '$10 each. A failure of either of those persons to release any one of those claims would be a breach of the bond ; and for any such breach a just compensation might be estimated in damages. The sum of $10,000 must therefore be regarded as simply a penalty to secure the payment of such damages as the obligee may suffer from any breach of the bond. Watts v. Camors, 115 U. S. 353; Boys v. Ancell, 5 Bing. N. C. 390 ; S. C. 7 Scott, 364; Thompson, v. Hudson, L. R. 4 H. L. 1, 30; Fish v. Gray, 11 Allen, 132.
Upon the evidence introduced and the admissions made by the plaintiff at the trial, it does hot appear that he suffered any damage whatevor. Although there was a technical breach of the bond at the expiration of a year from its date, by the third persons therein named having failed to release the plaintiff from any of the debts held by them, yet, within a month afterwards, and before this action was brought, he was legally discharged from all those debts by obtaining a certificate of discharge in bankruptcy. This discharge was not the less complete and effectual because the creditors had not received payment in full, nor because the plaintiff might, if he saw fit, by new promises to them, waive the discharge and revive so much of the debts as had not been satisfied by the dividends paid by the assignee in bankruptcy.
Judgmentfor nominal damages affirmed.