Newhall v. Breton
Syllabus & Case Posture
NEWHALL v. LE BRETON.
APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT .OF THE UNITED STATES FOR THE DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA.
Argued November 2, 1886.
Decided November 29, 1886.
The evidence in this case, if admissible, establishes as a fact that the defendant was entitled to reimburse himself in full out of the trust estate before satisfying the demand of the plaintiff.
This action was commenced in the Superior Court of the State of California for the city and county of San Francisco, and removed thence to the Circuit Court of the United States.The material allegations in the complaint were the following:
Opinion of the Court — Me. Justioe HaelaN
Primary OpinionMe. Justioe HaelaN
delivered the opinion of the court.
The amount secured to be paid by the deed of trust executed on the 1st day of October, 1870, by Juana M. Estudillo and others to Theodore Le Hoy, was $446,849 in gold coin of the United States. Whether that sum included the- $49,000 which is alleged to be due to Patterson, Wilson, Crittenden, and Felton for legal services rendered, cannot be determined by anything in the deed itself. The plaintiff, who sues as assignee of the claims of said attorneys, is compelled to resort to parol evidence to show that the parties to the deed intended to provide for the payment of the $49,000 out of the proceeds of the sale of the trust property, and to that end included it in the aggregate- of $446,849. If that evidence was competent, it-was the right of the defendant to show by parol evidence that the intention of the parties was to apply .the proceeds of sale to the reimbursement of Le Koy, for all advances and payments made and expenses incurred by him, before anything was paid on the claims of the attorneys. Looking at all the evidence, we are satisfied that these propositions are sustained, namely : 1. That the $49,000 was embraced in the $446,849; '2. Tbe former sum was not to be paid until Le Roy was reimbursed tbe entire amount dub. and to become due to bim on account of principal, interest, advances, and expenses. That tbe sales of tbe trust property fell short of meeting these latter demands by a large amount, is clearly established by the record of tbe suit in which tbe accounts of the trustee were audited and settled, and by other evidence in this cause. Upon tbe whole case we think the decree was right, and it is
Affirmed.