Crowell v. McFadon
Syllabus & Case Posture
*Crowell and others v. McFadon.
Seizure — Embargo.
Under the 11th section of the embargo act of 25th April 1808, the collector was justified in detaining a vessel, by his honest opinion, that there was an intention to violate or evade the provisions of the embargo laws. It was not necessary for him to show that his suspicion was reasonable.
Error to the Supreme Judicial Court of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts. The case, as stated by Duvall, J., in delivering the opinion of the court, was as follows :
An action of trover for. 650 barrels of flour, of the cargo of the schooner Union, was brought by John McFadon against Joseph Otis and the appellants, in the court of common pleas for Suffolk county, in the commonwealth of Massachusetts, where a trial was had and judgment rendered in favor of the defendants. From this decision there was an appeal to the supreme judicial court of that state, in which the cause was again tried and a verdict and judgment rendered for the plaintiff for $3716.30 and costs. Joseph Otis ' died, whilst the suit was depending in the supreme judicial court.
The following are the principal facts appearing on the record in this case : The schooner Union, Benjamin Hawes, commander, with a cargo of 650 barrels of flour, and five tons of logwood, shipped by John McFadon, of Baltimore, was cleared at that port for Machias, in Massachusetts, late in the month of April, in the year 1808. She had originally cleared for Passamaquoddy, on the 16th of April, before the collector had received notice of the act of the 25th of the same month, which authorised him to detain the vessel: the destination was changed to Machias, and a clearance obtained accordingly. But the original destination of the flour on board, for East-port, remained on the face of the manifest. The flour was shipped for account and risk of Josiah Dana, of Machias, and in his absence, Jonathan Bartlett, of Eastport, or his assigns.
Opinion of the Court — Duvall, J.,
Primary OpinionDuvall, J.,
after stating the facts of the ease, delivered the opinion oi the court, as follows : — This court is unanimously of opinion, that the direction of the judge of the supreme judicial court of Massachusetts was erroneous. The law of congress under which the collector acted is clear and exjilicit. The collector was bound by law to seize and detain the Union, on her arrival in his district, if, in his opinion, it was the intention to violate or evade any of the provisions of the embargo laws, and his conduct was approved and confirmed by the president. The landing and storing the cargo, whether to preserve it from injury or to secure it from ruin (which, in this case, was done with the consent of the agent of the owner), was a necessary consequence of the detention. The law places a confidence in the opinion of the officer, and he is bound to act according to his opinion; and when he honestly exercises it, as he must do in the execution of his duty, he cannot be punished for it. The judgment of the court below is reversed, with costs.
Judgment reversed.
Judge Livingston was absent when this opinion was delivered. Judge Stoky gave no opinion, having some impression that he was, at a former period, retained as counsel in the cause, although he did not remember arguing it.