SCOTUS-Cases.net

The Frances

12 U.S. 335 1814-03-12 4,801 Words
Full Case Caption
The Frances, Boyer, master: Thompson et al., claimants
Official & Parallel Citations
8 Cranch 335 · 12 U.S. 335 · 3 L. Ed. 581
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 12 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

*The Frances, Boyer, master: Thompson et al., claimants.

Prize. — Domieil.

A naturalized citizen, who, in time of peace, returns to his native country, for the purpose of trade, but with the intention of returning again to his adopted country, continuing in the former a year after the knowledge of the existence of war between the two countries, for the purpose of winding up a complicated business, and engaging in no new commercial transactions whatever with the enemy, and actually returning to his adopted country in a little more than a year after his first knowledge of the war, is to be considered as having gained a domicil in his native country; and his goods, captured after the war, liable to condemnation.*

Goods appearing by the ship’s papers to be a consignment from alien enemies to American merchants, condemned in toto as prize, although further proof was offered that American merchants were jointly interested, and that they had a lien upon the goods, in consequence of advances made by them. Further proof on these points refused.

This was an appeal from the sentence of the United States’ Circuit Court for the district of Rhode Island. The facts were as follows :

War was declared by the United States against Great Britain, on the 18th of June 1812. The ship Frances, having on board a cargo of goods of British manufacture, consigned to various persons in the United States, sailed from Greenock, in Scotland, on the 19th of July, in the same year, for New York. On the 28th day of August following, she was captured by the Yankee privateer, and carried into the district of Rhode Island, whore the cargo was libelled as enemy property.

Opinion of the Court — Marshall, Ch. J.,

Primary Opinion

Marshall, Ch. J.,

after stating the facts of the case, delivered the opinion of the court, as follows : — The rights of James Thompson depend entirely on his national commercial character ; which is decided by the opinion given in the case of The Venus (ante, p. 253). The sentence of condemnation pronounced in the circuit court, as to James Thompson’s claim, is affirmed.

The original evidence is very strong to prove that the shipment made by Dalgleish & Frame was entirely a consignment. The whole letter of the 13th of July confirms this idea. It is scarcely credible, that the property of Dalgleish & Frame would have been placed on the list of consignments, without a note upon it, had it been shipped on joint account. The hurry of business will not excuse or account for this omission. The proposition of Dalgleish & Frame is stated to have been made on the 27th of June, and to have been accepted on the 1st of July. The letters of Thompson to Steele are written on the 13th and 17th of July, when this shipment is treated as being altogether a consignment. The hurry could not have been such as to account for a mis-statement of the fact. There is, too, something .mysterious in the manner in which the papers, offered as additional proof, reached Mr. Steele. That they should not have been accompanied by a letter, nor bear any marks of coming from abroad, is singular. *Further proof is not admitted, and the sentence is affirmed.

Wednesday, March 16th. (Absent, Marshall, Ch. J.) Washington, J., as to the opinion of the court on the question of lien, referred to the opinion delivered in the case of The Trances (Irvin’s claim, post, p. 418), which he said was precisely within the principle of the present case.

Sentence affirmed.

Cited By Later Decisions (2)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).