SCOTUS-Cases.net

The Grotius

12 U.S. 456 1814-03-16 2,186 Words
Full Case Caption
The Grotius, Sheafe, Master
Official & Parallel Citations
8 Cranch 456 · 12 U.S. 456 · 3 L. Ed. 623
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 12 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

The Grotius, Sheafe, Master.

Validity of capture.

Question as to the validity of capture; one man only having been put on board; the ship’s papers and the navigation of the vessel being left to the master. Further proof ordered.

Appeal from the sentence of the Circuit Court for the district of Massachusetts.

*457] The Grotius, an American ship, owned by Thomas Sheafe and Charles Coffin, the claimants, sailed from Portsmouth, New Hampshire, March 2d, 1812, on a voyage, according to the shipping paper, from Portsmouth to one or more southern ports, and from thence to one or more ports in Europe, and back to her port of discharge in the United States, and to Portsmouth, if required. She arrived at New York, and sailed from thence, with a cargo for St. Petersburg, and arrived at Cronstadt on the 17th of June 1812. The cargo was owned by American merchants, and was consigned to a house at St. Petersburg. The consignees furnished a return-cargo on the credit of the outward cargo. After the return-cargo was put on board, the French armies having entered Russia, and threatening to approach St. Petersburg, the consignees were apprehensive that their security for the return-cargo might be lost. They arrested the ship and cargo, and would not permit her to *depa.rt, but on condition that she should proceed to London, with the cargo then on board, and that the master should sign bills of lading to deliver the property in London, to the order of the consignees ; they stipulating that if they should have obtained payment from the proceeds of the outward cargo, the bills of lading should be given up to their owners or agents íd London, and the cargo then to be at the disposition of the master.

The news of the war between the United States and Great Britain having reached St. Petersburg, the American ships in that port (fifty or sixty in number), with the knowledge and approbation of Mr. Adams, the American minister at the Court of St. Petersburg, sailed for England with British licenses. This was resorted to, as the only course in which it was possible to get home. The Grotius sailed, among others, with such license. Owing to the lateness of the season, she put into Carlscrona, Sweden, where she lay from the 28th of November 1812, until the 25th of March 1818. On the 2d day of May following, she arrived at London, and there discharged her cargo, consisting of iron, hemp and cordage, and on the 17th of June following, departed for the United States, in ballast. On the 29th of July, she was captured by the privateer Frolic, John Odióme, commander, who put one man on board of her from the privateer. The captain of the Grotius kept his papers and the command of his ship, and navigated her to Boston. On her arrival, she was libelled in the district court of Massachusetts.

Opinion of the Court — Washington, J.,

Primary Opinion

Washington, J.,

delivered the opinion of the court, in this case, as follows : — This case differs in no material respect from that of The Joseph, just decided, except that in this a question arises as to the validity of the capture. The master of the Grotius, in answer to the second standing interrogatory, swears that he hath never considered the ship to have been taken or seized as prize. That he was present when an armed schooner, under English col-•Ü -j ors, met with her, the commander of which represented her *to be a J British privateer called the Bream, and requested him to take on board a man, and treat him as a gentleman, until he arrived in the United States ; to which he consented. This testimony of the master is confirmed by Gilman, the mate, in answer to the 2d and 3d interrogatories, who adds, that Very, the man who was put on board, never conducted as prize-master, nor in any other manner than a passenger would, during the voyage. Pierce, one of the seamen, who accompanied the master on board the schooner, swears that he never knew the ship was seized as prize, until after her arrival within the Boston light-house. Chambers, another seaman belonging to the Grotius, in answer to the third interrogatory, says that she was met by an armed schooner, under English colors, which obliged the mate of the ship go on board her, and afterwards sent him back with a man who, on the next day, declared himself to be put on board as prize-master, saying that if she should fall in with a French vessel, he should be obliged to show his commission. That he knows not upon what pretence or for what reasons he was taken, not knowing, in fact, that she was made prize of, until her arrival at Boston.

Daniel J. Very, the alleged prize-master, has deposed, on oath, that he was present at the capture of the Grotius by the Frolic ; that the master of the ship was ordered on board the schooner with his papers ; and that he, Very, was directed by his commander to go on board as prize-master, and this in the presence of the master of the Grotius ; that the master of the ship was to keep possession of the papers, and to navigate her into port. That he accordingly went on board as prize-master, carrying with him a copy of the commission of the Frolic ; and instructions, in writing, from the commander to him (Very) as prize-master. That the master of the Grotius informed his crew, that in case a British cruizer should board the Grotius, and they should be asked respecting the said Very, they were to answer that he was a passenger.

Without giving any opinion as to the regularity of admitting the affidavit of the prize-master as a part of the preparatory evidence, the court is of opinion, that the facts necessary for deciding upon the validity of the ^capture, are not sufficiently clear ; and that it will be proper to p make an order for further proof, to be furnished by the captors and >- the claimants, with respect to all the circumstances of the capture. This point appears not to have been made or considered in the court below.

Order for further proof.

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).