SCOTUS-Cases.net

Baker v. Power

124 U.S. 167 1888-01-16 893 Words
Full Case Caption
BAKER v. POWER
Official & Parallel Citations
124 U.S. 167 · 31 L. Ed. 382 · 8 S. Ct. 416
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 124 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

BAKER v. POWER.

■APPEAL FEuU THE CIECUIT COUET OF THE. UNITED STATES FOE THE DISTRICT OF MINNESOTA.

Submitted January 9, 1888.

Decided January 16, 1888.

An appeal can be taken from a decree of a Circuit Court of the United States, entered under the supervision and by the direction of the district judge of the district sitting in the Circuit Court, although he may under the provisions of Rev. Stat. § 614, have, had no right to a .vote in the ■cause.

Motion to dismiss, “because the judgment in the Circuit 'Court from which this appeal ivas taken was rendered without consent of appellees by the judge of the United States District Court of said district, sitting in the Circuit Court upon an appeal from .his decision as district judge.” The following statement accompanied the motion.

Opinion of the Court — Me. Chief Justice "Waite

Primary Opinion

Me. Chief Justice "Waite

delivered the opinion of the court.

This motion ■ is denied. If it be true, as is alleged, but which is by no means clear, that the decree appealed from was rendered by the district' judge when he had no vote in the cause, we still have jurisdiction of the appeal. Although the district judge may have had no right to a vote, he was rightfully a member of the Circuit Court, Rodd v. Heartt, 17 Wall. 354, 357, and a decree of that court entered under his super-’ vision and by his direction'would be a decree of the court, good until reversed or otherwise vacated. From such a decree an appeal can be taken.

Denied.

Precedents Cited (1)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).