SCOTUS-Cases.net

Munson v. Mayor of New York

124 U.S. 601 1888-02-13 1,571 Words
Full Case Caption
MUNSON v. MAYOR, ALDERMEN AND COMMONALTY OF THE CITY OF NEW YORK; MAYOR, ALDERMEN AND COMMONALTY OF THE CITY OF NEW YORK v. MUNSONN
Official & Parallel Citations
124 U.S. 601 · 31 L. Ed. 586 · 8 S. Ct. 622
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 124 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

MUNSON v. MAYOR, ALDERMEN AND COMMONALTY OF THE CITY OF NEW YORK. MAYOR, ALDERMEN AND COMMONALTY OF THE CITY OF NEW YORK v. MUNSONN.

APPEALS FBOM THE CIBCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED 'STATES FOB THE SOUTHEBN DISTBICT OF FEW YOBK.

Argued' February 2, 3, 1888. —

Decided February 13, 1888.

A blank book, with pages numbered and ruled into -spaces, in which bonds and their coupons on being presented and paid, may be pasted in the order of their numbers — the bonds on successive pages, and each bond and its coupons on the same page — or, when any bond or coupon is paid without being surrendered, memoranda concerning it may be made, if under any circumstances a patentable invention, is not so if similar books have been in use before, differing only in grouping the coupons according to their dates .of payment, and in having no spaces for the bonds.

This was a bill in equity by Francis Munson against the' Mayor, Aldermen and Commonalty of tbe City of New York and the comptroller of the city, for the infringement of letters patent granted to Munson on April 2, 1867, for “ new and useful improvements in preserving, filing and cancelling bonds, coupons, certificates of stock, &c.,” consisting, as described in the specification, “ in providing a book or other register with pages corresponding in size, style and number with the bonds, coupons, certificates, &c., to be used, on which pages the said bonds, coupons, or other certificates, when paid, are pasted or otherwise attached, and thus preserved and cancelled, as hereinafter more fully explained.”

Opinion of the Court — Me. Justice Gbay,

Primary Opinion

Me. Justice Gbay,

after stating the case as above reported, delivered the opinion of the court.

What the plaintiff, in different parts of his specification, calls his “ improvement,” his “ system,” and his “ invention,” consists in providing one or more blank books, resembling common scrap-books, of which each page will hold a bond and its coupons, and has a heading describing the bond, and all the pages are numbered and ruled into spaces, in which the bonds and the coupons, on being presented and- paid, may be pasted in the order of their numbers — the bonds on the successive pages, and the coupons of each bond on the same page with it — or, when any bond or coupon is paid without being surrendered, memoranda concerning it may be made. The claim is for the so preserving, filing and verifying of the bonds and coupons, and for the book so constructed and used.

If upon the face of the specification this could be considered as' an “ art, machine, manufacture, or composition of matter,” within the meaning of the patent laws, (upon which we express no opinion,) it is quite clear that, in the state of previous knowledge upon the subject, there was no patentable novelty in tbe plaintiff’s scheme; inasmuch as the only difference between it and the earlier scheme of "Warren was that in Warren’s books there was no place for the bonds, and the coupons were grouped according to their dates of payment, instead of being grouped together with the bonds to which they respectively belonged. The providing of spaces for the bonds, and the change in the order of arrangement of the coupons, cannot, upon the most liberal construction of the patent laws, be held to involve any invention.

Decree reversed, wild case remanded to • the Circuit Court, with directions to (dismiss the. bill; the original plaintiff to pay the costs in both counts.

Cited By Later Decisions (1)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).