SCOTUS-Cases.net

Brock v. Northwestern Fuel Co.

130 U.S. 341 1889-04-08 No. 210 487 Words
Full Case Caption
BROCK v. NORTHWESTERN FUEL COMPANY
Official & Parallel Citations
130 U.S. 341 · 32 L. Ed. 905 · 9 S. Ct. 552
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 130 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

BROCK v. NORTHWESTERN FUEL COMPANY.

ERROR TO THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF IOWA.

No. 210.

Argued and submitted March 19,'1889.

Decided April 8, 1889.

When it does not appear, affirmatively, from the record that the Circuit Court had jurisdiction, the judgment below will be reversed and the cause remanded for further proceedings-in accordance with law. '

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice Harlan

Primary Opinion

Mr. Justice Harlan

stated the case as above reported and delivered the opinion of the court.

The act of 1875 declares that no Circuit or District Court shall have “cognizance of any suit founded on contract in favor of an assignee, unless a suit might have been prosecuted in such court to recover thereon if no assignment had been made, except in cases of promissory notes negotiable by the' law merchant and bills of exchange.” 18 Stat. 470. It does not appear that the What Cheer Land and Coal Company, the plaintiffs’ assignor, could' have brought suit on the contract in question, if no assignment had been made. The record does not show of what State it is a corporation. The allegation that it was “ doing business in the State of Iowa ” does not necessarily import that it was created by the laws of that State. But if that allegation were held sufficient to show it was an Iowa corporation, the result would be the same, because, in that case, it would appear that the parties to the original contract weré all citizens of Iowa, and consequently that the assignor could not have sued the defendants in the Circuit Court of the United States.

The judgment is reversed upon the ground that it does not appear, affirmatively, from the record that the Circuit Court had jurisdiction, Metcalf v. Watertown, 128 U. S. 588, and. the cause is remanded for further proceedings in. accordance with law.

jReversed.

Cited By Later Decisions (3)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).