SCOTUS-Cases.net

Stevens v. Nichols

130 U.S. 230 1889-04-01 No. 190 749 Words
Full Case Caption
STEVENS v. NICHOLS
Official & Parallel Citations
130 U.S. 230 · 32 L. Ed. 914 · 9 S. Ct. 518
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 130 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

STEVENS v. NICHOLS.

ERROR TO THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF MISSOURI.

No. 190.

Arguéd March 11, 1889.

Decided April 1, 1889.

A petition for removal which alleges the diverse citizenship of the parties in the present tense is defective, and if it does not appear in the record that such diversity also existed at the commencement of the action, the cause will be remanded to the Circuit Court with directions to send it back to the state court, with costs against the party at whose instance the removal was made.

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice Harlan

Primary Opinion

Mr. Justice Harlan

delivered the opinion of the court.

1. It was held in Robertson v. Cease, 97 U. S. 646, 649, upon writ of error from a Circuit Court of the United States, that “ in cases where jurisdiction depends upon the citizenship of the parties, such citizenship, or the facts which in legal intendment constitute it, should be distinctly and positively averred in the pleadings, or they should appear affirmatively .and with equal distinctness in other parts of the record.” Mansfield, Coldwater &c. Railway v. Swan, 111 U. S. 379, 382; Hancock v. Holbrook, 112 U. S. 229, 231; Thayer v. Life Association, 112 U. S. 717, 719; Continental Ins. Co. v. Rhoads, 119 U. S. 237, 239.

2. The case was not removable from the state court, unless it appeared affirmatively in the petition for removal, or elsewhere in the record, that at the commencement of the action, as well as when the removal was asked, Stevens and Mirick were citizens of some other State than the one of which the plaintiff was, at those respective dates, a citizen. Gibson v. Bruce, 108 U. S. 561, 562; Houston & Texas Central Railway v. Shirley, 111 U. S. 358, 360; Mansfield, Coldwater &c. Railway v. Swan, 111 U. S. 379, 381; Akers v. Akers, 117 U. S. 197.

3. The petition for removal does not allege the citizenship of the parties except at the. date when it was filed, and it is not shown elsewhere in the record that Stevens and Mirick were, at the commencement of the action, citizens of a State other than the one of which the plaintiff was, at that date, a citizen. The court, therefore, cannot consider the merits of the case. Metcalf v. Watertown, 128 U. S. 586; Morris v. Gilmer, 129 U. S. 315, 325.

The judgment is reversed upon the ground that it does not appear that the Circuit Court had jurisdiction, and the case is remanded to that court, with directions to send it back to the state court, the plaintiff in error to pay the costs in this court and in the court below. Mansfield &c. Railway v. Swan, 111 U. S. 379.

Reversed.

Precedents Cited (9)

Cited By Later Decisions (16)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).