SCOTUS-Cases.net

Glenn v. Fant

134 U.S. 398 1890-03-24 No. 357 1,027 Words
Full Case Caption
GLENN v. FANT
Official & Parallel Citations
134 U.S. 398 · 33 L. Ed. 969 · 10 S. Ct. 583
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 134 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

GLENN v. FANT.

ERROB TO THE SUPREME COUBT OE THE DISTRICT' OE COLUMBIA.

No. 357.

Argued March 11, 1890.

Decided March 24, 1890.

A stipulation was filed in tljis cause to the effect that the court should con- . sider the cause as if the general issue and other named pleas had been ■pleaded and issue joined; that the cause should be heard upon “an agreed statement of facts annexed with leave to refer to exhibits filed therewith; ”■ and that the cause might be submitted to the court to decide on such statement, exhibits and pleadings. No bill of exceptions was taken, there was no finding of facts by the court below, nor was any case stated by the parties, analogous to a special verdict, stating the ultimate facts, and presenting questions of law only; Held, that this stipulation could not be regarded as taking the place of a special verdict, or a special finding of facts, and that this court had no jurisdiction to determine the questions of law thereon arising.

Opinion of the Court — Me. Chief Justice Fullee delivered the opinion of the court.

Primary Opinion

Me. Chief Justice Fullee

delivered the opinion of the court.

No ■ bill of exceptions was taken in this case, nor was there any finding of facts by the Supreme Court of the District of Columbia, nor any case' stated by the parties analogous to á special vérdict and stating the ultimate facts of the case, presenting questions of law only. What is styled here an “ agreed. statement, of facts” is an agreement as to certain matters, and that the .parties might refer to and rely upon any and all grounds of action or defence to be found in two voluminous exhibits, marked X and Y, being the records of two equity causes in other -courts, including all the pleadings and evidence, as well as the orders and decrees therein. The effect of .some of that evidence and of the conclusions of fact to be drawn from' it is controverted. It is impossible for us to regard this' stipulation as taking the place of a special verdict of a jury, or a special finding of facts by the court, upon which our jurisdiction could properly be invoked to determine the questions of . law thereon arising. And while the case is governed by the rule laid down in Campbell v. Boyreau, 21 How. 223, yet, even if the statutory provisions in relation to the trial of causes without the intervention of a jury by the Circuit Courts of the United States were-applicable, the result upon this record would be the same. Raimond v. Terrebonne Par ish, 132 U. S. 192; Andes v. Slauson, 130 U. S. 435; Bond v. Dustin, 112 U. S. 604; Lyons v. Lyons Bank, 19 Blatchford, 279.

The judgment must be

Ajfu'med.

Precedents Cited (4)

Cited By Later Decisions (5)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).