SCOTUS-Cases.net

California v. San Pablo & Tulare Railroad

149 U.S. 308 1893-05-10 No. 257 2,544 Words
Full Case Caption
CALIFORNIA v. SAN PABLO AND TULARE RAILROAD COMPANY
Official & Parallel Citations
149 U.S. 308 · 37 L. Ed. 747 · 13 S. Ct. 876
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 149 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

CALIFORNIA v. SAN PABLO AND TULARE RAILROAD COMPANY.

ERROR TO THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA.

No. 257.

Argued April 24, 1893.

Decided May 10, 1893.

If, pending a writ of error to reverse a judgment for the defendant in an action by a State to recover sums of money for taxes, the defendant offers to the plaintiff, and deposits in a bank to its credit, the amount of those-sums, with penalties, interest and costs, which by a statute of the State have the same effect as actual payment and receipt of the money, the-writ of error must be dismissed.

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice Gray

Primary Opinion

Mr. Justice Gray

delivered the opinion of the court.

Upon the fact most properly and frankly admitted in open court by the Attorney General of the State of California, there can be no doubt that this writ of error must be dismissed-, because the cause of action has ceased to exist. Any obligation of the defendant to pay to the State the sums sued for in this case, together with interest, penalties and costs, has been extinguished by the offer to pay all these sums, and the deposit of the money in a bank, which by a statute of the State have the same effect as actual payment and receipt of the money. And the State has obtained everything that it could recover in this case by a judgment of this court in its favor. The duty of this court, as of every judicial tribunal, is limited to determining rights of persons or of property, which are actually controverted in the particular case before it. When, in determining such rights, it becomes necessary to give an opinion upon a question of law, that opinion may have weight as a precedent for future decisions. But the court is not empowered to decide moot questions or abstract propositions, or to declare, for the government of future cases, principles or rules of law which cannot affect the result as to the thing in issue in the case before it. No stipulation of parties or counsel, whether in the case before the court .or in any other case, can enlarge the power, or affect the duty, of the court in this regard.

The case at bar cannot be distinguished in principle from previous cases in which writs of error have been dismissed by this court under similar or analogous circumstances. Lord v. Veazie, 8 How. 251, 255; Cleveland v. Chamberlain, 1 Black, 419; Wood Paper Co. v. Heft, 8 Wall. 333; San Mateo County v. Southern Pacific Railroad, 116 U. S. 138; Little v. Bowers, 134 U. S. 547; Singer Manuf. Co. v. Wright, 141 U. S. 696. See also Elgin v. Marshall, 106 U. S. 578.

Writ of error dismissed.

Precedents Cited (8)

Cited By Later Decisions (28)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).