SCOTUS-Cases.net

Laidlaw v. Organ

15 U.S. 178 1817-02-20 5,909 Words
Full Case Caption
Laidlaw et al. v. Organ
Official & Parallel Citations
2 Wheat. 178 · 15 U.S. 178 · 4 L. Ed. 214
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 15 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

(local law. y

Laidlaw et al. v. Organ.

Error to the district court for the Louisiana district.

The defendant in error filed his petition, or libel, in the court below, stating, that on the 18th day of February, 1815, he purchased of the plaintiffs in error one hundred and eleven hogsheads of tobacco, as appeared by the copy of a bill of parcels annexed, and that the same, were delivered to him by the said Laidlaw & Co., and that he was in the lawful and quiet possession of the said tobacco, when, on the 20th day of the said month, the said Laidlaw .& Co., by force, and of their uwn.wróng, tbok possession of the same, and unlawfully withheld the same from the petitioner, notwithstanding he was at all times, and still was, ready to do and perform all things on his part stipulated to be done and performed in relation to said purchase, and had actually tendered to the said Laidlaw & Co. bills of exchange for the amount of the purchase money, agreeably to the said contract; to his damage, &c.' Wherefore the petition prayed that the said Laidlaw & Co. might be cited to-appear and answer to his plaint, and that judgment' might be renderad against them for his damages, &c. And inasmuch as the petitioner did verily believe that the said one hundred and eleven hogsheads of tobacco Would be removed,, concealed, or disposed of by the said Laidlaw & Co., he prayed that a writ of sequestration might issue, and that the same might, be se-. qüestered in the hands of the marshal, to abide the judgment of the court, and that the said one hundred and eleven hogsheads of tobacco might be finally adjudged to the petitioner, together with his damages, &c., and costs of suit, and that- the petitioner might have such other and farther relief as to the court should seem meet, &c.

The bill of parcels referred to in the petition was in the following words and figures, to wit:

“ Mr. Organ Bo’t of Peter Laidlaw é¿ Co. Ill Hhds. Tobacco, weighing 120,715 pounds n’t. fr. $7,544.69.

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Chief Justice Marshall

Primary Opinion

Mr. Chief Justice Marshall

delivered the opinion of the court.

The question in this case is, whether the intelligence df.éxtrinsic circumstances, which might influence the price of the commodity, and which was exclusively within the knowledge of the vendee, ought to haye been,,communicated by him,to the vendor? 'j’he court is of opinion that he Was not bound to communicate it. It Would be difficult to circumscribe the contrary doctrine within proper limits, where tho means of intelligence are equally accessible to both parties. But at the same time, each party must take care not to say or do any thing tending to impose upon the other. The court thinks that the absolute instruction of the judge was erroneous, and that the question, whether any imposition was practised by* the vendee ¡upon the Vendor ought to have béen submitted to the jury. For thesareasohs the judgment must be reversed, and the cause'remanded to the district court of Louisiana, with directions to award a venire facids de novo,

Venire-de novo awarded.

Cited By Later Decisions (6)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).