SCOTUS-Cases.net

Saltonstall v. Birtwell

150 U.S. 417 1893-12-04 No. 116 986 Words
Full Case Caption
SALTONSTALL v. BIRTWELL
Official & Parallel Citations
150 U.S. 417 · 37 L. Ed. 1128 · 14 S. Ct. 169
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 150 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

SALTONSTALL v. BIRTWELL.

ERROR TO THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES FOR THE DISTRICT OF MASSACHUSETTS.

No. 116.

Argued November 24, 1893.

Decided December 4, 1893.

Hndings of fact in an action brought to recover duties on importations paid under protest, which do not show what the collector charged the .plaintiff, nor sufficiently describe the articles imported, and a record . which fails'to show under what provisions' of the tariff act the parties claimed respectively, leave this court unable to direct judgment -for either party.

Opinion of the Court — Mjr. Chief Justice Fuller,

Primary Opinion

Mjr. Chief Justice Fuller,

after stating the case, delivered the opinion of the court.

We are of opinion that the facts set .forth in the special findings are not sufficient to support the judgment. • The-findings (jo not show what the collector charged the plaintiff; nor sufficiently describe the articles imported; nor does it appear from the record under what provisions of the tariff act of-March 3, 1883, 22 Stat. 488, c. 121, the parties claimed - respectively. The opinion might help the findings out, but cannot be resorted to for that purpose. Dickinson v. Planters' Bank, 16 Wall. 250.

We.are unable, therefore, to direct judgment for either party. Chesapeake Ins. Co. v. Stark, 6 Cranch. 268, 273; Harden v. Fisher, 1 Wheat. 300, 303; Barnes v. Williams, 11 Wheat. 415; McArthur v. Porter’s Lessee, 1 Pet. 626; Ex parte French, 91 U. S. 423; Ryan v. Carter, 93 U. S. 78, 81; Hodges v. Easton, 106 U. S. 408, 411; Fort Scott v. Hickman, 112 U. S. 150, 165; Tyre & Spring Works Co. v. Spalding, 116 U. S. 541, 545, 546 ; Allen v. St. Louis Bank, 120 U. S. 20, 30, 40; Raimond v. Terrebonne Parish, 132 U. S. 192; Lloyd v. McWilliams, 137 U. S. 576.

Judgment reversed and cañóse remamdedfor a new trial.

Precedents Cited (12)

Cited By Later Decisions (5)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).