Jackson ex dem. People v. Clarke
Syllabus & Case Posture
(common LAW )
Jackson, ex dem. The People of the State of New-York, v. Clarke.
G. C., born in the colony of New-York, went to England in 1738, where he resided until his decease; and being seized of lands in NewtYork, he, on the 30th of November, 1776, 'in England, devised the same to the defendant, and E.‘C.,as tenants in common; and died so seized on the 10th December, 1776.. The defendant and E. C. having entered, and becoming possessed, E. C. on tile 3d December, 1791 ' bargained and sold to the defendant all bis interest. The defendant and E. C. wore both born in England long before the revolution. On thp twenty-second of March, 1791, the legislature of New-Yoik passed an net to. enable the defendant to purchase lands, and to hold all otlioi . lands which he might then lie entitled to within the stale, by nurchase or descent, in fee simple, and to sell and dispose of the same in the game manner as any natural born citizen might do. The treaty between the United States and Great Britain of 1794, contains the following provision : “Article 9th. It is agreed that British subjects who now hold lands in the territories of the United Slates, and American citizens who now bold lands in the dominions of his majeaty, shall continue to hold them according to the nature and tenure of their respective estates and titles therein; and may grant, sell, or devise the same to whom they please, in"lrl?e manner as if they were natives, and that neiiber they, nor tliei r.heirs, or assigns shall, so far as respects ilia said lands and the legal remedies Incident thereto, be considered as aliens.” The defendant atibe time of the action brought, still continued to be ,a British subject. Held, that he was entitled to hold tho lands so devised to him by G. C., and transferred to him hy E. C.
Error to the circuit court for the district of New-York.
This was an action of ejectment commenced in the supreme court of the state of New-York, and (removed thence into the circuit court of the United States, for the New-York district, where, in 'September, 1815, a trial -was had, and a special verdict found, in - the words following, to wit:
At which day in this same court, at the city of New-York, in the New-York district, came the parties aforesaid, by their attorneys aforesaid, and the jurors aforesaid being called also come, who to say the truth of the above contents, being elected, tried and swprn, say, upon their oath, that long before the above mentioned time, when the trespass and ejectment above mentioned, are supposed to have been committed, namely, on the tenth day of' April,,'1706, Anne, Queen of England, by letters patent under the great s.eal of the then colony of New-York, did grant unto-Sampson Broughton, and divers other persons in the said letters patent named, and their heirs, a certain tract of land, situate in the then colony, now state of New-York,-to have and to hold the-same to them, their heirs and assigns, forever, as tenants in common, and not as joint tenants. And that the lands and tenements, with their appurtenances specified in the foregoing declaration of the said James Jackson, were part and parcel of the said tract of land granted, as aforesaid, by the said letters patent. And the jurors aforesaid, upon their oath aforesaid, further say, that the said Sampson Broughton, and the said other persons to whom the said tract of land was granted as aforesaid by the said letters patent, being so seized in-fee simple, and possessed of the said tract of land by virtue of the said letters pateni; did afterwards, to wit: on the twelfth day of April, in the year last aforesaid, by good and sufficient cqnveyance and assurance in the law, for a valuable consideration, grant, bargain, sell, and convey unto George Clarke, now deceased, (who was formerly lieutenant governor of the said colony, and who was then a subject -of England, and who remained so until the time- of his death,) and- to his heirs, one equal undivided ninth part of the said tract of land granted as aforesaid, in and by the said letters patent, to have and to hold to him, his heirs and assigns, forever. And the jurors aforesaid,-upon their oath afo.resaid, further say, that partition of the said tract of land mentioned in the said letters patent was afterwards; to wit, in the year last aforesaid, made in due form of law, between the last aforesaid George Clarke, and the other proprietors of the said tract of land mentioned and granted in and 'by the said letters patent. And that by virtue, of the said partition, the- last aforesaid George Clarke became, and was sole seized in fee simple, and possessed' of the lands and tenements, with the appurtenances specified in the said declaration of the said James Jackson, and coritinueifI.:to be so seized and .possessed thereof, ^e'time.of his death. And that the. last aforesaid George .Clarke died so seized and possessed, in the year-1759. And the jurors aforesaid, upon their oath aforesaid,.further say, that George Clarke, who was late-secretary of the colony of'New-York, was the eldest son, and heir at law of the before mention- • ed George Clarke, formerly lieutenant governor, as aforesaid. And that upon xne death of the- said George Clarke, formerly lieutenant .governor as aforesaid, the said George' Clarke, • late secretary as aforesaid, as.spn and heir, ■ as aloresaidi, entered up:* on, .and was seized in fee simple,- and possessed' the lands and .tenements,'with the appurtenances specified in the said declaration of the said James Jacksdn. .'And being so seized and possessed, did afterwards, to wit, on the thitieth day of November, 1776,' at Hyde, in the county palatine of Chester,, in the kingdom of Great Britain, make and publish, in due form of law to pass real estate, his last will and . testament, and did thereby devisy xxnto his grand' nephews, the said George Clarke, the- defendant in thp -said declaration named, and Edward - Clarke, and to their heirs and assigns, as tenants in common, and not as joint tenants, the lands and tenements in the said declaration specified, with the appurtenances. Arid the jurors aforesaid, upon their oath aforesaid, furthe'r say, that'the said George Clarke, late secretary as aforesaid, afterwards, to wit, on the tenfti day of December, 1776, at Hyde aforesaid, in the said county palatine of Chester, in the said kingdom of Great Britain, died so seized and possessed as aforesaid, and without having altered or revoked his said last will and testament. And .the jurors aforesaid,'upon their oath aforesaid, further say, that upon the death of the said George Clarke, late secretary as aforesaid,- the. said 'George Clarke, the. said defendant, and the said Edward Clarke, claim.ing under the- said last will and testament, entered "upon, and became possessed of, the- said .lands and tenements, with the appurtenances, in the said declaration specified.. And the said George Clarke, .the said defendant, and the said Edwa.rd Glarke,.being actually-possessed.of the said land's and tenements,"with the appurtenances, in the said declaration specified, as under the said last -will and testament, the said Ed\vard Clarke did afterwards, to wit, on the twént-y-third day of December, 1791,.by a deed of bargain and sale, duly executed, grant, bargain, and sell, for a valuable consideration, tó the ' said George Clarke, the said de-. fendant, and his heirs* one equal moiety of the said, lands and tenements, with the appurtenances, in the said declaration specified!, and all the estate and interest of the said Edward Clarke, in and to the said lands pnd tenements last aforesaid, with the appurtenances, to have and to hold the same to the said George piarke, the said defendant, his heirs, and assigns; by reason, whereof, fhe said'George Clarke,.the said defendant,entered upon, and became, ánd was actually possessed of, the said lands and tenements, whh the appurtenances, in the said declaration specified, claiming to-be seized thereof in fee simple, and so continued, until the entry of the .people of the state oí New-York, hereafter mentioned. And the jurors aforesaid upon their oath aforesaid, further say, that the said George Clarke., late secretary as aforesaid, was born in the city of New-York, in the late colony, now state of New-York,. and that in the year 1738 he went to that part of Great Britain called England, and thenceforth continued -to live, and reside there ' on His family estate until and at the time when he made and published his said last will and testament, and ever after, and until and at the time of his death. And the jurors aforesaid, upon their oath aforesaid, further say, that on ttie fourth day of July, in the year 1776, the late colony, of New-York, together with the other colonies of Great Britain in North America, now called the United States of America, declared themselves free and independent states, and that frpm that, day to the first day of September, in the year 1783, the said United States, and the citizens thereof, were at open and public war with the king of Great Britain and his subjects. And the jurors aforesaid, upon their oath aforesaid, further-say, .that the said George Clarke, the said defendant, was born, in England, on the twenty-eighth day of April, inthe-year 1768. And that the said Edward Clarke was bom in'England, on the twenty-eighth day of November, in the year of bur Lord 1770. And that the said George Clarke, the sáid defendant, and the said Edward Clarke, wele both British subjects.
Opinion of the Court — Mr. Chief Justice Marshall
Primary OpinionMr. Chief Justice Marshall
delivered the opinion of the court, that every question arising in the cause had been settled by former'decisions.
Judgment affirmed, with costs.
In the. case of M‘Ilvaine v. Coxe’s lessee, 3 Cranch, 209, the court determined that a personborn in the colony otNewJersey, before the declaration of independence, and residing there until 1777, hut who then joined the. British army, and ever sineeadheredtotheBritish government, has a right tó lakelands by descent in the state of New-Jersey. But in Dawson’s lessee v. Godfrey, 4 Cranch, 321, it was held that a person born in England before the declaration of independence,and who always resided there, and never was in the United Stupes, could not take lands in Maryland by descent.
And in the case of Smith v. the State of Maryland, 4 Cranch, 286, it was determined that by the acts of Maryland, 1780,ch, 45 and 49, the equitable interests of British subjects in lands were confiscated; and vested in the state, without office found, prior to the treaty of peace of 1783, so that the British ceslúi que trust was not protected by the stipulation in that treaty, against future confiscations, nor by the stipulation in the 9tb article of the treaty of. 1794, securing to British subjects, who then held lands in this country, the right to continue to hold them.
In the supreme court of N. York it has been held, that where a married woman was a subject of Great Britain before the revolution, arid always continued such, but her husband, resided in this country both before and after, that period she was entitled to dower out of those lands of which he was seised befere -the revolution, but not of those of which he was subsequently seised. Kelly v. Harrison, 2 Johns. Cas. 29. The sarhe court has also determined, that where a British subject died seized of lands in file state in 1752, . leaving ■daughters in England who married British subjects, and nei. ther they nor their wives were citizens of the Unitted States! even if the marriages were subsequent to the revolution, such marriages would notimpair the rights of the wives, nor prevent the full enjoyment of the property according, to the laws of the marriage state, especially after the 5th provision in the 9th article of the treaty ofl794 The court seemed also to think that where the title to land in the state was acquired by a British subjeetprior to the revolution; the right of such British subject to transmit the same by descent, to an heir in esse at the time of the revolution, continued unaltered and unimpaired,- the case of a revolution or division of an empire being an exception to the gen-rule of law,' that an alien cannot take bv descent. Jackson v. Lunn. 3 Johns. Cas. 109. also Jackson v. Wright, 4 Johns. R. 75. The treaty of 1704, relates only to landa'//ierc held by British subjects, and not to any after acquired lands. Jackson v. Decker, 11 Johns. R. 418, 422.
In the case of Fairfax’s devisee v. Hunter’s lessee, 7 Cranch, 603, and ante, vol. I. p. 304. it was adjudged, 1st. That an alien enemy may' take by purchase though not by descent; and that, vWiether the purchase be by grant or'by devise. 2d. That the title thus acquired by an alien enemy is no devested until office found-3d. That whether the treaty of peace of- 1783, declaring that no future confiscations should be made, protects from forfeiture, under the municipal laws respecting alienage, lands held by British subjects at the time of its ratification, or not, yet that the 9th article of the •treaty of 1794 completely protected the title of.a British devisee, whose estate had pot been preyiously devested .by an inquest-of office, or some eqivalent proceeding