Shepherd v. Hampton
Syllabus & Case Posture
(Common Law.)
Shepherd et al. v. Hampton.
In an action by the vendee for the breach erf a contract ofsqlb oy the vendor, in not delivering the .articlo, the measure of damage ¡8 the price of the article at the time of the breach of the contract, and not-at any subsequent period.
Quiere, How far this rHle applies to a ease where advances ofmoney , .have been made by the purchaser under the contract?
Error to the district court of Louisiana.
The plaintiffs filed their petition or libel in. the court below, stating, that on the 12th day of December, 1814, they énteré-d .into a contract with the defendant, for the purchase oi 100/000 pounds weight of cotton to be delivered by the defendant to the' plaintiff's on or before the 15th day of February, ensuing.the date'of said contract, the said cotton to be of prime quality, and in good order,, and for which the plaintiffs stipulated to pay at the rate of ten cents peí1 French pound; and in case the price ot cotton, at the time of delivery, should exceed the above limited price, then the' petitioners were to allow the coipmom market price on 50,000 pounds of said cottons and alleging a breach of the agreement on the- part of,the defendant in not delivering the cotton, & c.
Opinion of the Court — Mr, Chief Justice Marshall
Primary OpinionMr, Chief Justice Marshall
delivered the opmiua of the court. The only question is, whether the price. of the article at the time of the breach of the contract, or at any subsequent time before suit brqught, const!-' ^es Ujg pr0per rule of damages in this case. The unanimo «8 opinion, of the - court' is, that the price of the article at the time it was to be delivered, is the measure of damages; For myself only, I can say that I should not think the rule would apply to a case where advances of money had been made by the purchaser under the contract; but I am not aware what would be ¡the opinion of .the court in such a case.
Tudgment affirmed.