SCOTUS-Cases.net

Astor v. Wells

17 U.S. 466 1819-02 6,323 Words
Full Case Caption
Astor v. Wells et al.
Official & Parallel Citations
4 Wheat. 466 · 17 U.S. 466 · 4 L. Ed. 616
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 17 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

(CHAKCERY — LOCAL LAW.)

Astor v. Wells et al.

Under the registry act of Ohio, which provides, that certain deed» “ shall be recorded, in the county in which the lands, tenements, and hereditaments, so convoyed or affected, shall be' situate,, within one year after the day on which such deed or conveyance was executed ; and, unless recorded in the manner and within the time ■ aforesaid, shall be deemed fraudulent against any subsequent bona . fide purchaser without knowledge of the existence of such former deed of conveyance:” lands lying in Jefferson county were conveyed by deed ; and a new county, called Tuscarawas county, was erected, partly from Jefferson, after the execution, and before the recording of the deed, in which new county the lands were included; and the deed'was recorded in Jefferson. Held, that this registry was not sufficient ,either to preserve its legal priority, or to give it the equity resulting from constructive notice to a subsequent purchaser.

Notice of a prior incumbrance to an agent is notice to the principal. Under the statute of fraudulent conveyances of Ohio, which provides, that “ every gift, grant, or conveyance of lands, tenements, héréditáments, &c. made or obtained with intent to defraud creditors of their just and lawful debts or damages, or to defraud or deceive the person or persons who shall purchase such lands, &c. shall be deemed utterly void, and of no effect:” Held, that a bena fide pur- ■ chaser, without notice, could not be affected by the intent of the grantor to defraud creditors.

. Appeal from the Circuit Court of Ohio.

The bill in equity filed in this cause states, that Arnold Henry Dorhman, in 1806, became indebted to the United States, in the.sum of 6,515 dollars and 10 cents, for duties upon the importation of certain goods payable at the custom-house in the city of New-York. The plaintiff, Henry Astor, became bound with Dorhman for the payment of those duties; and, thereupon, Dorhman, to secure Astor, executed and delivered the mortage deed of the 14th of August, 1806, in the bill mentioned, for the 13th township, in 7th range, then lying in Jefferson county, in the State of Ohio: and Dorhman became farther indebted to the plaintiff in the sum of 2,700 dollars, to secure which, upon said township, he afterwards, on the 25th of August, 1807, executed another 'mortgage deed of the same premises. Both the deeds were recorded in the county of Jefferson; on the 2d of October, 1810, and in Tuscarawas on the 21st of October, 1812, which county was erected in part from Jefferson, after the execution, and before the recording therein of said deeds.. On the 26th of August, 1807, the plaintiff released to Dorhman one fourth of said township, by deed recorded in. Tuscarawas county on the 9th of March, 1813. On the 24th of October, 1810, Dorhman gave the defendant Wells a deed of trust of the three fourths of said township not released, to secure the payment of 5,000 dollars, for which the defendant Wells had become liable for Dorhman, by endorsing his paper at the bank of Steubenville, which was re- . corded in Tuscarawas, the 13th of January, 1811. On the 12th of February, 1813, the defendant Weils took another deed from Dorhman for the quarter or sections which had been released, which was recorded in Tuscarawas-county on the 10th of March,. 1813, to secure 3,000 dollars, for farther endorsements by Wells for Dorhman. The bill then charges the defendant Wells with notice of the plaintiff Js deeds and lien upon said lands, before his deeds, endorsements, or any payments made by him; and that he accepted the deeds, made the endorsements, and payments, if any, with knowledge, &c.; charges a secret understanding, that the released sections, conveyed to Wells, by the last mentioned deed, were to enure to Dorhman or his family; and that neither, transaction between Wells and Dorhman was bona fide. Dorhman died on,the 21st of February, 18113, nine days after his last deed' to Wells, who commenced a suit against the heirs of Dorhman on the 27th of August following; and obtained a decree of sale, under which he purchased the premises; all which is charged to be fraudulent. The widow and heirs of Dorhman, by their answer, admit all the deeds, and answer, generally, that they know nothing of the other transactions. The answer of Wells admits the plaintiff’s deeds; states his own deeds to be bona fide-, and denies notice and fraud. Obadiah Jennings, who was examined as a witness in the , cause, testified, that he prepared the first deed to Wells, and Saw it executed, but says that Dorhman employed him, and he considered himself exclusively employed by Dorhmán, and not as. the agent or attorney of Wells, in that transaction ; that it was probable he had held some convérsaíion with Wells as to his liabilities for Dorhman,. and the nature Of the ; security to bé given before Dorhman applied.to him to draw the deed; ¡and that Wells sent the deed to. him in a letteiy to cany to be recorded in Tuscarawas county. Dorhman informed him that Astor’s. agent had brought Astor’s deeds and put them o& record ; and Dorhman wished to give Wells, the pre- , ference, and consulted him how it could be done. The witness examined the record, and knew, of As-7 . tor’s deeds and lien on those lands. He advised Dorhman to give Wells a deed, which, if recorded in Tuscarawas, would give him the preference; but never gave Wells any information respecting Astor’s deeds.

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice Johnson

Primary Opinion

Mr. Justice Johnson

delivered the opinion of the

Court. The questions in this case are partlyof law, partlyof fact. The bill charges the. defendant with express notice of the complainant’s previous mortgage, and with holding the land purchased under a secret trust,for the legahrepresentatives of Dorhman, the mortgagor. Both these facts the answer denies ; and as there is no evidence to - sustain them,.they must.be put out of the. case.

The bill then proppses to affect the defendant, Wells, with constructive notice ; and if it fails there, then to set aside the deed to Wells as absolutely void under the express provision of a law of the State of. Ohio.

Obadiáh Jennings, who drew the mortgage from Dorhman to Wells, was fully apprised ©f the exis-. tence of Astor’s mortgage, and acted in concert with Dorhman expressly to defeat Astor’s prior lien, and give precedence to Wells. The advantage of which they proposed to avail themselves for this purpose, was a supposed- mistake committed by Astor as to the legal office for recording his deed. The land was originally comprised within the limits of Jefferson county. But before the recording of the deed, the county of Tuscarawas was taken off from Jefferson, 'and the land lay in that part of Jefferson which thus became Tuscarawas county. The law of Ohio' requires that the recording shall take place in the County in which the land lies.

The first question is, was this a legal recording under the laws of Ohio, so as to preserve the priority which dates gave to Astor ? The office of Jefferson county was the legal office at the time of executing the deed: did it continue to be so at the time of recording it ? This can only be decided by considering the object of the law.' It was to give notice to subsequent, purchasers — to place at. their command the means of investigation, to which, if they did not resort, they had only to blame their own indolence or folly. But no one in search of such information respecting lands situate in Tuscarawas county, would be expected to search the records of Jefferson subsequent to the. date of the separation. He would naturally refer to the records of the new county to its origin, and from that time pursue his inquiries among the records of the county in which it was originally comprised. And, therefore, we are of opinion, that the recording of Astor’s deed was not sufficient, either to preserve its legal priority, or give it the equity resulting from constructive notice.

But it is contended, that Jennings was the mutual agent of both mortgagor and mortgagee in the creation of Wells’ mortgage, and, therefore, the notice to ■xx'r 11 tt • i Jennings was notice to Wells. Here, again, the com- ° ® . * plainant’s case is unsupported by the evidence. On the law there could be no doubt, if the facts wére such as the complainant contends. But it is positively denied both by Wells and Jennings; and if Jennings was the agent of Dorhman only, his knowledge could produce no other effect on the rights, of , . Wells than if. it had been concealed in the breast of Dorhman. And this leads to the final question in the case. „ As the deed really was “ made” to defraud Astor, does that circumstance alone, under the laws of Ohio, destroy its validity, without reference to the knowledge or connivance of the mortgagee. And this again must be decided by referring to the object (,jie |aWo The words of the statute would literally embrace the'case. But who are the objects of the law ? Not creditors only, but subsequent purchasers. And to give it such a construction as would expose a bona fina purchaser without notice to imposition, in order to protect creditors, could never eomport with the intent of the law.

Upon the whole, we are of opinion, that there is no error in the decree below, and that the same be affirmed, with costs.

Decree affirmed, with costs.

Cited By Later Decisions (5)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).