SCOTUS-Cases.net

M'Iver's Lessee v. Walker

17 U.S. 444 1819-02 2,364 Words
Full Case Caption
M'Iver's Lessee v. Walker et al.
Official & Parallel Citations
4 Wheat. 444 · 17 U.S. 444 · 4 L. Ed. 611
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 17 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

(local law.)

M'Iver’s Lessee v. Walker et al.

If, there is nothing in a patent to control the call for course and distance, the land must be bounded by the courses and distances of . the patent, according to the magnetic meridian. ' But it is a general' principle, that the course and distance must yield to natural objects called for in the patent. .

-All lands are supposed to be actually, surveyed* and .the intention of the grant is to convey the land according to the actual surrey; consequently, • distances must be. lengthened or. shortened, and courses varied, so as to conform to the natural .objects called for.

If a patent refer to a plat annexed, and if in that plat, a water course be laid down as running through the land, the tract must be so surveyed as to include the water course, and to conform as nearly as may be to the plat, although the lines, thus run, do .not correspond with the courses and distances mentioned in the patent; and . although neither the certificate of survey nor the patent calls for that water course.

Error to the Circuit Court for the District of East Tennesee. This was an ejectment brought in that Court by the plaintiff in error against the defendants. Upon the first trial of the cause, a judg-. ment was rendered in the Circuit Court in favour of the defendants, and upon thát judgment a writ of error was taken out, and the judgment reversed by this Court, at February Term, 1815; and the causé was sent back to be tried according to certain directions, prescribed by this Court.

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Chief Justice Marshall

Primary Opinion

Mr. Chief Justice Marshall

delivered the opi- March im. nioaof the Court.

The Cotirt has re-examined the opinion which it gave5 when this cause was formerly 'before it, and has not perceived any reason for changing that opin¡on< Nor do the new facts introduced into the cause, in any material degree, vary it. if there had been a settled course of decisions in Tennessee upon their local laws, different from the judgment pronounced by this Court, we should not hesitate to follow those decisions. But, upon an examination of the cases cited at the bar, we do not perceive that such is the fact. The judgment of the Circuit Court is, therefore, reversed, and the cause remanded for farther proceedings.

Judgment. — This cause came bn to be heard on the transcript of the record, and was argued by counsel. On consideration whereof, it is the opinion of this Court, that the Circuit Court erred in the instructions given to the jury: it is, therefore, Adjudged and Ordered, that the judgment of the Circuit Court for the District of East Tennessee, in this - cause, be, and the same is, hereby reversed and annulled. And it is further ordered, that the said cause be remanded to the said Circuit Court for farther proceedings to be had therein, according to law.

Precedents Cited (1)

Cited By Later Decisions (3)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).