Stone v. Farmers' Bank
Syllabus & Case Posture
STONE, Auditor, v. FARMERS’ BANK OF KENTUCKY. FARMERS’ BANK OF KENTUCKY v. STONE, Auditor.
Nos. 385, 386.
Argued February 28, March 2, 1899.
Decided May 15, 1899.
The decree below, so far as it granted the relief prayed as against the defendants other than the city of Georgetown and the county of Scott, is affirmed by a divided court; and, so far as it adjudicated against the complainant and in favor of the defendants the city of Georgetown and the county of Scott, those defendants not having been parties or privies to the judgments pleaded as res judicata, is affirmed upon the authority of the decision in Citizens' Savings Bank of Owensboro v. Owensboro, 173 U. S. 636.
These appeals were taken from a decree rendered in a suit in equity brought by the Farmers’ Bank of Kentucky against Samuel H. Stone, auditor, Charles Findly, secretary of State, and G. W. Long, treasurer of the Commonwealth of Kentucky, constituting a state board of valuation and assessment ; the board of councilmen of the city of Frankfort; the county of Franklin; the city of Henderson; the county of Henderson; the city of Georgetown; and the county of Scott. The object of the bill and of an amended and supplemental bill was to restrain the valuation of the franchise of the complainant under the provisions of a revenue act of Kentucky, enacted November 11, 1892, as also the certification of such valuation and the collection of taxes thereon for the years 1895, 1896, 189? and-1898.
Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice White,
Primary OpinionMr. Justice White,
after making the foregoing statement, delivered the opinion of the court.
The decree below, so far as it granted the relief prayed as against the defendants other than the city of Georgetown and the county of Scott, is affirmed by a divided court. The decree, so far as it adjudicated against the complainant and in favor of the defendants the city of Georgetown and the county of Scott, those defendants not having been parties or privies to the judgments pleaded as res judicata, must be affirmed upon the authority of the decision in Citizens’ Savings Bank of Owensboro v. City of Owensboro and A. M. C. Simmons, Tax Collector, 173 U. S. 636.
And it is so ordered.