SCOTUS-Cases.net

Bowie v. Henderson

19 U.S. 514 1821-03-12 1,392 Words
Full Case Caption
Bowie v. Henderson et al.
Official & Parallel Citations
6 Wheat. 514 · 19 U.S. 514 · 5 L. Ed. 319
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 19 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

(Local Law.)

Bowie v. Henderson et al.

Thfe-third section of the act of Congress, of March 30th, 1803, for the r.elief of -insolvent debtors in the District of Columbia, • does not create any express or implied'exception to the operation of the statute of limitations, by making the insolvent a trustee for his ^creditors, in -respect to his future property,, or by making any demand, included- in the schedule of his debts, a debt of record.

The including of a'demand in the schedule, of the insolvent’s debts, is sufficient evidence t,o sustain an issue on a replication óf a new'promise to the plea of the statute of limitations, if the period of limitation has not elapsed after the date of the schedule.

Appeal from the Circuit Court of the District of Columbia»

This suit was instituted by the appellant against the respondents, on the Chancery side of the Circuit Court of the District of Columbia, for the county of .. . . iiiii ■. . . Alexandria, under the local-law giving a process in Chancery in the nature óf a foreign attachment.

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Chief Justice Marshall,

Primary Opinion

Mr. Chief Justice Marshall,

delivered the opinion, of the Court, and after stating the case, proceeded as follows:

It is perfectly clear that no such exception is contained in. the statute of limitations, or- in the act of Congress concerning insolvent debtors If it is to be created .at all, it must be by implication, ft is contended in., the first place, that the insolvent debtor, after his discharge, is to be considered in respect to hisfutlííe,'property, as a trustee for his creditors; and-the statute of limitation does not run against a trust. If hé isa trustee, for his creditors, is he a trustee for those creditors only who were such at the - time, he obtained the benefit of the act ? or, is he a trustee for those who afterwards become his creditors ? It will not be pretended that he is exclusively a trustee for the former: and if he bé a trustee for the benefit of all his creditors, then this suit should, have been brought for the benefit of all, and not.for the benefit of a single creditor. The proviso Of the section respecting the liability of the future property of the insolvent, has been supposed to aid the argument that he is a trustee : But we áre all of a different opinion the previous part, of the section having exempted his person from imprisonment, the object 01 the proviso was to make all his future ■ effects liable, aud io retain all the remedies, against it, in the same mannér.as if his person had not been discharged. The.act, therefore, did not intend to create any new liability, or any new trust.

It.is farther insisted, that this is to be considered as an exception out of the statute Of limitations, because it is a debt of record. But á debt of record, in the sense of the common law, is a debt or contract created of record ; such as a statute staple, or statute merchant, and not one whose previous existehce is only admitted of record. The effect of recording this debt was merely an admission of its existence, and not a change of its nature, it would have been sufficient evidence, if five years had not elapsed after recording, to have sustained an issue on a replication of a new promise to the plea of the statute of limitations. But more than five years having elapsed, it could have no application in this case. It is the opinion of the Court, that the demurrer to the replication is sustained, and that judgment ought tobe given for the defendant.

Decree affirmed.

Cited By Later Decisions (1)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).