Smith v. Payne
Syllabus & Case Posture
SMITH v. PAYNE.
APPEAL FROM THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA.
No. 481.
Argued March 10, 1904.
Decided April 11, 1904.
What are periodicals and second class matter decided on authority of Houghton v. Payne, ante, p. 88.
Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice Brown
Primary OpinionMr. Justice Brown
delivered the opinion of the court.
Plaintiffs are the publishers of several different series of novels under the names of The Columbia Library, The Bertha Clay Library, The Magnet Detective Library, The Medal Library, The Undine Library, The Eden Series, The Arrow Library, and some others. The books of these series are apparently of an inferior class of literature, and are numbered consecutively; but the only thing to indicate that they are issued periodically is a notice upon the outside of the back cover in small type that they are weekly or semi-monthly publications.
The considerations moving us to affirm the decree of the Court of Appeals in the case of Houghton v. Payne, just decided, apply with much greater persuasiveness to this case, and the decree dismissing the bill is, therefore
Affirmed.
Dissenting Opinion — Mr. Justice Harlan and The Chief Justice
Mr. Justice Harlan and The Chief Justice
dissent in this casé for the reasons stated in their, dissenting opinions in Houghton v. Payne, ante, p. 88, and Bates & Guild Co. v. Payne, post, p. 106.