M'Minn v. Owen
Syllabus & Case Posture
M'Minn versus Owen.
THIS was an action of covenant on articles of agreement, dated 22d January, 1779; by which the plaintiff sold to the defendant a plantation, and the defendant covenanted to pay £500 immediately, and £500 in annual instalments. The first payment was made, and bonds were given for the residue of the money.
The question now principally agitated, was—whether the money was to be reduced by the scale of depreciation, or to he paid in gold and silver?
The plaintiff offered a witness to prove, that, at the time of the covenant being executed, it was agreed the instalments should be paid in whatever money was current, at the time they became due.
Ingersoll, on the part of defendant,
objected to this testimony. The value of money in contracts between 1776, and 1781, is ascertained by the act of Assembly (1 Vol. Dall. Edit. p. ) No parol, proof is to be admitted to contradict this: It has always been repelled. It was so in Lee v. Biddis. 1 Dall. Rep. 175. The bonds which are explanatory of the contrast are given to be paid in “lawful money of Pennsylvania.” The evidence offered is to vary the agreement. Where the parties reduce the agreement to writing, that alone is the rule; 2 Bl. Rep. 1249. Even conversation of the parties at the time of the contract is not admitted, unless there is fraud. Brown. Ch. 93. 4. Powell. 430. Ambiguous expressions are not to be explained by parol proof; So was the case of Benezet and M'Clenachan where proof being offered to shew that by the term “specie,” used in a policy of insurance, certain paper bills were intended by the underwriters, it was refused.
Opinion of the Court — Shippen, Justice:
Primary OpinionShippen, Justice:
—In Graff versus Whitmer, it was deter mined in this Court, that such proof might be made ; and even after judgment by esault, in debt on bond, the cause was sent to auditors to ascertain the value or kind of money. I cannot in consequence say such proof ought to be rejected; and this very point has been settled in that of Hurst versus Kirkbride.
By the Court :—Let the evidence be heard, and the point reserved for the defendant, if he shall think it proper to move for a new trial.
The verdict being for plaintiff, a motion for a new trial was accordingly made, and argued by Ingersoll, at the same time with the case of Field and Biddle : (Ant. p. 171) But the counsel for the plaintiff submitted the point without argument. And
By the Court :—The rule must be discharged.