SCOTUS-Cases.net

United States v. Insurgents of Pennsylvania

2 U.S. 335 1795 3,783 Words
Full Case Caption
The United States versus The Insurgents of Pennsylvania
Official & Parallel Citations
2 Dall. 335 · 2 U.S. 335
Court & Volume
United States Circuit Court for the District of Pennsylvania · 2 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

The United States versus The Insurgents of Pennsylvania.

SEVERAL indictments for high treason having been found against persons concerned in the insurrection in the four Western Counties of Pennsylvania, a Venire was issued in each case, for summoning a Jury returnable to the present Term ; and to each writ the Marshall returned a separate pannel, containing the names of thirty-six Jurors, from the city of Philadelphia fifteen from the county of Delaware, nine from the county of Chester and twelve from each county, in which the treason was charged to have been committed, making seventy-two Jurors on each pannel, and one hundred and eight Jurors summoned on the whole.

The act of Congress (1 Vol. p. 112. s. 29) having directe“ that any person who shall be accused and indicted of treason, shall have a copy of the indictment, and a list of the Jury and witnesses to be produced on the trial for proving the said indictment, mentioning the names and places of abodes of such witnesses and jurors, delivered unto him at least three entire days before he shall be tried for the same,” the Attorney of the District had, in due time, delivered to the several prisoners copies of the indictment, of the pannel of jurors, and of the lilt of witnesses ; but he had omitted to deliver a copy of the caption of the indictment, and to specify the occupations, or the places of abode of the jurors and witnesses, otherwise that by mentioning the counties in which the jurors respectively resided.

.On this ftate of faéls, Lewis fuggefted the following except tions ¾ which, he faid, were not' fo much defigried for the exifting cafes,, as to prevent the introduction of precedents, injurious to the rights and fafety of pofterity.

1st. That the Marshall had returned a greater number of Jurors than the law authorized ; and that he had returned a several pannel in each case, instead of one general pannel to try all the issues at this Court.

By the act of Congress (1 Vol. p. 67. s. 29. ) it is declared, that “ in cases punishable with death, the trial shall be had in the county where the offence is committed, or where that cannot be done, without great inconvenience, twelve pettit Jurors at least shall be summoned from thence. And jurors in all cases to serve in the Courts of the United States shall be designated by lot, or otherwise, in each state respectively, according to the mode of forming Juries therein now practiced, so far as the laws of the same shall render such designation practicable by the Courts or Marshalls of the United States ; and the Jurors shall have the same qualifications as are requisite for Jurors by the laws of the State of which they are citizens, to serve in the highest Courts of law of such States and shall be returned as there shall be occasion for them, from such parts of the District, from time to time, as the Court shall direct,, so as shall be most favorable to an impartial trial, and so as not to incur an unnecessary expence, or unduly to burthen the citizens of any part of the District with such services.”

Opinion of the Court — Peters, Justice :—I Patterson, Justice:

Primary Opinion

Peters, Justice :—I

have considered the objections made to the pannels, and do not conceive these objections relevant.

Although in ordinary cases it would be well to accommodate our practice with that of the State, yet the Judiciary of the United States should not be fettered and controuled in its operations by a strict adherence to State regulations and practice. But I see not that in a liberal view and construction of the laws of the United States, on this subject, a rigid adherence to all the local and (economical regulations of the State, is directed or necessary. It should seem, that the most pointed reference was had to the designation and qualification of jurors, and not to the exact numbers of which the pannel should consist. The Legislature of a State have in their confideration a variety of local arrangements, which cannot be adapted to the more expanded policy of the nation. It never could have been in the contemplation of Congress, by any reference to State regulations, to defeat the operation of the national laws. Now, there are cases, which have been stated, in which some of the criminal laws of the United States may be rendered impracticable, by an adherence to the rule of numbers, prescribed as to jurors, in criminal cases by the State law ; and especially if there must be but one pannel, as has been contended. Yet, the most substantial requisites, to win the qualifications of jurors and mode of selection, may be adhered to. As to the clause in the law of the United States, directing, that the laws of the States (with great exceptions) shall be regarded as rules of decision, in trials at common law in the Courts of the United States," I do not think it applies to the case before us.

.All the arguments founded on the inconveniences to -the d'e-, fendants, if in this cafe particularly'any fuch-exift (of which T much doubt) weigh lightly when fet again.fi: the delays and ob-ftruftions which the objeflion would throw-in the way of the execution of the laws of the nation. ' *

Patterson, Justice:

—The objections that have been suggested on this occasion, are principally founded on the 29th section of the judicial act of Congress, which refers the Federal Courts to the State laws, for certain regulations respecting juries. But the words of this reference are clearly restricted to the mode of designating the jury, by lot, or otherwise, and to the qualifications which are requisite for jurors; according to the laws and practice of the respective States. Since, therefore; the act of Congress dies not itself fix the number of jurors ; nor expressly adopt any State rule for the purpose, it is a necessary consequence that the subject must depend on the common law; and, by the common law, the Court may direct any number of jurors to be summoned, on a consideration of all the circumstances under which the venire is issued. There are instances, indeed, where five juries have been summoned upon a trial for High Treason, in order that, after the allowance of the legal challenges, a competent number might still be ensured. In the present instance, the precept requires the Marshall to return at least 48 jurors 5 and he has not, in my opinion, been guilty of any excess, in the exercise of that discretion for returning a greater number, with which he is legally invested.

Neither is the mode of making his return justly exceptionable. As the act of Congress directs that 12 jurors shall be summoned from the County, in which the offence was committed, I cannot conceive any more proper, or more legal, way of proceeding, than by issuing a venire in each case ; and then there must, of course, be a separate pannel returned, in conformity to every writ. Thus, likewise, the act of Congress and the State act have been reconciled, and both put into operation ; 12 jurors being returned in pursuance of the former, and 60 jurors being returned in pursuance of the latter, law.

With respect to the objection, that a copy of the caption of the indictment has not been furnished to the prisoners, it may be observed, that, although the practice of Pennsylvania has been different, yet, the caption and the indictment seem naturally to form but one instrument; and copies of both should, therefore, be delivered under the provisions of the act of Congress. There can be little inconveniency in adopting this rule ; and it is calculated to avoid much difficulty and controversy.

The objection, that the place of abode of the jurors and witnesses, has not been sufficiently designated, in the lifts furnished to the prisoners, is, likewise, in our opinion, a valid one. The object of the law was to enable the party accused to prepare for his defence, and to identify the jurors who were to try, and the witnesses who were to prove, the indictment against him. It is contrary to the spirit and intent of such a provision, that the whole range of the State, or of a County, should be allowed, as descriptive of a place of abode ; and it is the duty of the Judges so to mould the practice and construction of statutes, as to render them reasonable and just. With regard to the place, therefore, we think the townships in which the jurors and witnesses respectively reside, should be specified; but the act of Congress does not require a specification of their occupations, and the niceties of the State act, are not, in that respect, incorporated into the Federal system.

In consequence of this decision, the trials were suspended, in order to give the Attorney of the District the three days required by the act of Congress, for delivering to the prisoners, amended copies of the caption and indictment, and of the lists of jurors and witnesses.

Cited By Later Decisions (2)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).