SCOTUS-Cases.net

United States v. Villato

2 U.S. 370 1797-04 1,690 Words
Full Case Caption
The United States versus Villato
Official & Parallel Citations
2 Dall. 370 · 2 U.S. 370
Court & Volume
United States Circuit Court for the District of Pennsylvania · 2 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

April Term, 1797.

Present—Iredell and Peters, Justices.

The United States versus Villato.

THE defendant had been committed by the District Judge, on a charge of High Treason against the United States, and on the return to a Habeas Corpus, issued under the act of Pennsylvania (2 Vol. Dall. Edit. p. ) it appeared, that he had entered on board of a French privateer “ in parts out of the territory of the United States, and that, having so entered, he aided in capturing an American vessel.”

But it was objected, by Dallas and Du Ponceau, for the prisoner, that he was not liable to a charge of High Treason because he was by birth a Spaniard, and had never become a naturalized citizen of the United States. They contended, therefore, that he ought to be discharged from the prosecution ; independent of any inquiry, whether the offence could be deemed High Treason, even in a citizen.

The facts were these:—Francis Villato was born within the dominions of the King of Spain ; he came from New Orleans to Philadelphia in the beginning of the year 1793, and, on the 11th of May following, he took, and subscribed, before, the Mayor of the City, the oath specified in the third section of the act of Assembly, passed on the 13th of March 1789. 2 Vol. Dall. Edit.p.676. He afterwards went to the West Indies, entered on board a French privateer, and a died as prize-matter of the American brig John of New-York, which the privateer had taken, while he was on board, and procured to be libelled and condemned at Cape Francois.

Opinion of the Court — Peters, JuJlice. Iredell, Justice.

Primary Opinion

Peters, JuJlice.

At the time of committing the defendant, some doubts arose in my mind ; which, on account of the importance of the subject, I thought it more proper to submit to a solemn discussion, than hastily to decide at my chambers. I take the earliest opportunity, however, to acknowledge, that I am now convinced the commitment was erroneous. The act of assembly is obviously, inconsistent with the existing constitution of the state ; and, therefore, cannot be saved by the general provision of the schedule annexed to it. On that ground only my opinion is formed ; but it is sufficient to authorise a declaration, that the proceeding before the Mayor was, ipso facto, void ; that, the prisoner is not a citizen of the United States ; and that, consequently, he must be released from the charge of High-Treason.

Iredell, Justice.

I am of the fame opinion. Difficulties, it is true, have been suggested on points not necessary to a decision on the present occasion ; and, certainly, if the question had not previously occurred, I should be disposed to think, that the power of naturalization operated exclusively, as soon as it was exercised by Congress.

But the circumstances of the case now before the court, render it unnecessary to enquire into the relative jurisdictions of the State and Federal governments. The only act of naturalization suggested, depends upon the existence, or non-existence, of a law of Pennsylvania ; and it is plain, that upon the abolition of the old constitution of the state, the law became inconsistent with the provisions of the new constitution, and, of course, ceased to exist, long before the supposed act of naturalization was performed.

The Prisoner must, therefore, be discharged.

Cited By Later Decisions (2)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).